The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SmolDrago]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110595395&userid=34940&signature=jG55DcJYNyUE9CDyK00UQg

Mmm yeah I agree with the person above me, it's probably more unfair to you. New store pets = 1 old rare (I think 2010/2011 is the year used as the benchmark?) So a 2014 VR is probably worth more like 2-3 store pets maybe? Plus the new token pets usually end up as EUC/rare so I'd say they need to add either the C$ equivalent of more store pets (if you prefer C$), or quite a few more recent rares/couple older rares

[abbie.]

could i have opinions on this?
how much does their side add up to?0:
thank u in advance !

[Jacki277]

How do you think about this trade:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110541024&userid=202481&signature=49uLg0EtbFmLoz-vlTSBkg

[Bunnyberry]

Hi! Just wanted opinions on this trade <3 any help is appreciated! Thank you sm 💗

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110547910&userid=626982&signature=UN15WEnhcR7ZehNYM8rCBg

[Audrey_Bee]

Hi! Just wanted opinions on this trade <3 any help is appreciated! Thank you sm 💗

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110547910&userid=626982&signature=UN15WEnhcR7ZehNYM8rCBg

Hey! I wouldn't take this, the malk smile has high demand and generally trades for 0.5MA, maybe a bit more for a true date as well, but at least 0.5 MA ! This would be 5 old rares so they would have to add at least another 3 old rares ! ❤️

Forum/search.php?keywords=Smiley&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

[Fluffle puffle]

Really not sure what to make of this one, ik my side is valuable but don't know quite how much
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110523152&userid=822924&signature=0KiTl3MDGcRWpJo9ldgamg

Unfair to you- those are worth 1MA each

Thank you!

[ACat]

Hi! Just wanted opinions on this trade <3 any help is appreciated! Thank you sm 💗

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110547910&userid=626982&signature=UN15WEnhcR7ZehNYM8rCBg

Personally I wouldn't take this. At face value it is fair, however the Malk Smiley does have some demand that I'd say would make it worth more than the dog :>

It seems to trade for about 0.5 MA !

Forum/search.php?keywords=Smiley&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

[SmolDrago]

Hi, I need help with this trade (not a huge one, don't worry ^^)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110315253&userid=1090308&signature=eC4lMO5V1QUfCPGm8nC3VQ

I'd say this looks mostly fair, to maybe slight underpay with demand considered. I think both the January 2011s would make up for the value of the pps just rarity wise, and the 2012 rare and EUC are a little extra for the 2021 VR. But I think that pps is staff/artist pet right? And usually old staff/artist litter pets trade for relatively higher than they're actually worth rarity-wise, because they're hard to come by individually, so there's greater demand for people trying to complete staff litter sets. And horses also tend to be lower demand pets. So it really is up to you if you don't care about demand, but you could probably get another older rare or two just based on the collector value for the artist pup.

[Doctor Wolf]

nvm

[Madel]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110586521&userid=841851&signature=sqNRT_mlQ5c6LAuKrCwNag
I really love the deer on my side, is 20 c$ fair for it?