The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Delta Dawn]

just would like a second opinion on this one; thank you!

The bengal trades for 1.5 nons, and the pumpkin pie goes for 1.5-2nons (usually on the lower end). The sunjewel pretty consistently goes for 3 nons, so this is fair, depending on how you value the pie.

[lurkie]

i got sent this and im not sure,, is any side overpaying? thank you so much lovely chicken smoothie residents

edit: and this please >.< clickie

♡

[Julaper]

I'm not sure what the demand for this pet is on my end. Would anyone be able to help me out?

They're probably just overpaying because it's a neat-looking dog.. there isn't any other reason for it to be worth another v-uc.

Thank you!

[keayi]

i got sent this and im not sure,, is any side overpaying? thank you so much lovely chicken smoothie residents

edit: and this please >.< clickie

♡

UR Peach = 1,5 NON

Sorb = 0,5 NON
Skeleton PPS = 0,25 NON
Whitestorm = 1 MA
Fairy Goat = 1 MA
Moonswirl Bun = 1 MA
Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, Ravenpaw = 0,5 MA/ea = 1,5 MA
Kitsune = 3 MA
Grown Cheetah = 0,5 MA
Flying Dog = 0,5 MA
Dark Leopard = 2 MA
10,5 MA= 1 NON(+,75 NON) = 1,75 NON so you're overpaying by 0,25 NON. Taking off 3-4 MA (or the Skeleton PPS) would be fairer

For the 2nd, I think 21 is decent especially if stores are sold at 20-25c$/ea and they are valued at a 2011 R/ea (and '12 VR = 2 '12 R = 1 '11 R)

[Get-a-Huhn]

Hey everyone,

could someone possibly tell me if this is fair? <3 Thank you so much!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108511734&userid=197971&signature=jfvzG0G5JKXbE2KDfDn-6w

[Julaper]

Every time I post on this thread, I get more crazy trades sent. How do we feel about this one?

[keayi]

Every time I post on this thread, I get more crazy trades sent. How do we feel about this one?

Seems unfair to you, I wouldn't take less than like a 2012 rare for each of the malks because they do have pretty good demand.

[Bee_Bovine]

Is this fair? I may be overpaying idk

[Julaper]

Every time I post on this thread, I get more crazy trades sent. How do we feel about this one?

Seems unfair to you, I wouldn't take less than like a 2012 rare for each of the malks because they do have pretty good demand.

Thanks again!

[WisteriaDragon]

Could I get some opinion(s) on this please?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108513011&userid=526141&signature=MpMA9cH_OiYsBpI2MFUHKQ