The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[slipknotmania]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108511184&userid=1086910&signature=rgv7nbssemXik-wYuVBZGw
Is this fair? I'm still figuring out the values of unknown rarity pets so I'm really not sure. Help would be highly appreciated!

[lurkie]

i got sent this and im not sure,, is any side overpaying? thank you so much lovely chicken smoothie residents

edit: and this please >.< clickie

♡

[Mewfles]

Trade here!
Need some help on this! Is it fair? What should be changed/what can make it fair

Ty whoever helps!

[Kenma Kozume]

I’m running an auction for two pets, and these are the offers I’ve gotten so far on them. If anyone would be able to let me know if these are fair, that would be amazing!! Thank you for any help in advance:)

Offer 1

Offer 2

Offer 3

[JustCharles]

Trade here!
Need some help on this! Is it fair? What should be changed/what can make it fair

Ty whoever helps!

Your blood devil pps is a low main worth around .25 to .5 non depending on how you really value it and can go from 25-67 098 rares. Theyre offering you the bare minimum at about 25 09 rares. Up to you past this info

[Kenma Kozume]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108511184&userid=1086910&signature=rgv7nbssemXik-wYuVBZGw
Is this fair? I'm still figuring out the values of unknown rarity pets so I'm really not sure. Help would be highly appreciated!

Hi — I think this is overpay on their side. The pet they’re offering for was a bit harder to get during the Halloween event, and they might just be desperate to complete their collection (Speaking from experience..) as for the unknown rarity — I don’t think that pet will be anything more than very uncommon tbh.

Basically, if you’re both happy with the offer I think it’s good and personally I would accept.

[answrs]

looking for some help on some more expensive leaning trades please. (store and older rares, not lists)

Koi/goldfish store for newer stores

09 malks for quantity (I am only looking for the 2017 pets and later, the older pets would go straight back into trade fodder if that makes a difference)

mostly asking if the rare swaps are about the same in terms of trading interest?

deeply appreciate any insight ^^

[GreedyCat]

looking for some help on some more expensive leaning trades please. (store and older rares, not lists)

Koi/goldfish store for newer stores

09 malks for quantity (I am only looking for the 2017 pets and later, the older pets would go straight back into trade fodder if that makes a difference)

mostly asking if the rare swaps are about the same in terms of trading interest?

deeply appreciate any insight ^^

The first trade is a pretty big overpay on their side since the 2014 koidogs go for .5-1 ma (leaning more towards 1)

[DarkWolf9875]

Still seeking help, thank you

Just wondering if I could get some input on this trade I just got, thank you

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108502479&userid=214650&signature=nTMaMEyQ2vlgh9glGKY5PA

[Soloee]

Bumping this

Is this a fair trade? It's a suggestion from them, so idk if it's actually not fair at all and I'm supposed to make a more fair suggestion back, or if it is pretty fair. (I usually just do monthly swap trades)