The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lurkie]

i got sent this and im not sure,, is any side overpaying? thank you so much lovely chicken smoothie residents

edit: and this please >.< clickie

[Kassit]

Is this a fair trade? I'm really not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108500137&userid=736471&signature=OdkNH1u2XhfMLbTaqsWjQQ

[angst]

just been on the fence about this one: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108495834&userid=866518&signature=9k_TDZKUcUVrH6_fyBKo_g

I am aware it is fair rarity wise, any thoughts on demand ?

Hey so this is a large group I wanted to trade for. I wanted to make sure I wasn't under paying for the amount of pets.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108509489&userid=223865&signature=NhbhDO5vb_ttSaVsjkGUTg

Thanks for the help!

I'd actually say you're overpaying date/rarity-wise! The uncommons and rare on your side are much older.

Did I make a fair offer for the Malk Smiley?

I know its worth SOMETHING but i dont understand the pet worth list or the math.

Looks like fair/slight overpay on your side! Malk smiley usually goes for 0.5 ma (3-4 2009 rares). I think the 2 2009 very rares would cover that (4 2009 rares worth).

What do TD VR warrior cats (in this case longtail, I think) go for?

Thank you!

Longtail went for 0.5 ma pre-rarity update and I still find it to be trading for that much, regardless of the date. If anyone has had a different experience though, feel free to pitch in!

Honestly that's what I expected since he's VR! But I wanted to make sure - thank you! I didn't even notice he was TD when I traded for him lol

[catplushie]

hello it's me again. is this fair? i'm not sure what their yellow butterfly wolf is worth.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108510198&userid=225037&signature=sbI08aEzLordQIJs8wLABQ

[shoob]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108510621&userid=1078676&signature=S3BS8_-i1cRbjqT1hgssVQ
Now I know this isnt fair on my part but I was wondering what would be a fair C$ add-on to my end of the deal? thanks!

[Fuzzy350]

I'm not very good at items values, can someone tell me if this is fair to both of us?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108505632&userid=962043&signature=ESqffkQ8175sH59Pk9rW3w

Still looking for help!

[ihavelice]

is this trade fair? link: _@_'-'

[Get-a-Huhn]

Is this trade fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108496973&userid=197971&signature=9Si4boKnHKBEXMJVtnfqSw

Someone help please? <3

[feverrr]

could i get some help with this? i know the earth day store deer is in quite high demand but i'm not exactly sure what it's worth.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108508567&userid=412872&signature=850jzw2H10CKr3hIgD13JQ

[keayi]

This post contains multiple answers to the trades posted above !!! As always FF to ask for another opinion ^o^

could i get some help with this? i know the earth day store deer is in quite high demand but i'm not exactly sure what it's worth.
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108508567&userid=412872&signature=850jzw2H10CKr3hIgD13JQ

It goes for at least 1,5 MA (9-12 '09 R) with demand so their offer is inadequate.

'21 Stores = '09-'10 R/ea = ~0,5 MA at best
'11 Medieval Faire Elf Items = '09-'11 R/ea
Reindeer Item = 2012 UC/R

is this trade fair? link: _@_'-'

IMO the bwolves are worth a 2010 R/ea (since they were priced 25-30c$/ea), so a 2010 VR is fair for two of them. It's hard to say what the remaining unknown rarities will be worth... the Halloween pet should hopefully come out as R which makes it fair for a 2020 rare, but I can't say for sure what the chikin nuggits (;0) will be worth. In short I would recommend editing your side down or not accepting

hello it's me again. is this fair? i'm not sure what their yellow butterfly wolf is worth.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108510198&userid=225037&signature=sbI08aEzLordQIJs8wLABQ

Yellow Poison Dart Bwolf = 0,5 MA = 4 '09 R
'17 Store = 1-2 '09 R
'10 VR = 1 '09 R

IMO I think they are overpaying by quite a bit. The '22 stores on your side should go for about a 2010 R/ea.

I'm not very good at items values, can someone tell me if this is fair to both of us? :)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108505632&userid=962043&signature=ESqffkQ8175sH59Pk9rW3w

Still looking for help!

The items are decently old (items are worth ~UC pet from the same year they were released). The bat will probably come out as rare, so it's upto you if you think they would be worth it.

Reindeer Antlers = 2012 UC
Wrapped Ribbon = 2013 UC
Green Skull Witch Hat = 2014 UC

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108510621&userid=1078676&signature=S3BS8_-i1cRbjqT1hgssVQ
Now I know this isnt fair on my part but I was wondering what would be a fair C$ add-on to my end of the deal? thanks!

I actually think the 20c$ more than covers it. If store pets are sold at 20-25c$/ea and you use 2:1 rule, then 2 '23 Stores = 1 '22 Store. I guess the additional 5-10c$ wouldn't hurt.