The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Sad Ghost]

Could someone help me figure out what would make this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108498031&userid=407077&signature=s3dtn96OBTwq4KqsrwL3Gw

[insomnia.]

is this a fair trade demand wise?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108498488&userid=340514&signature=IyD60y9vgSnPlALk_jArag

[.rin okumura.]

I'm not too good with item trades;
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108475870&userid=609153&signature=VtDRvx_5SymiNAsXAeQkhA

Would this be fair to me? I know some of the items they added in are older, so I'm not too sure

[misty,]

hello! is this fair? if not what would be fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108499048&userid=983261&signature=3M2Nw9c8mvTj0Yu3pV06mg
any help is appreciated, thank you:)

[keayi]

is this a fair trade demand wise?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108498488&userid=340514&signature=IyD60y9vgSnPlALk_jArag

Ik the Panda PPS is on the "regular VR" list (here), but I don't see the Coraline PPS on it, so it may be a former rare? Either way, they're both '09 VRs that aren't on the ex-list so I would consider this a fair swap

(I love ur pfp btw)

hello! is this fair? if not what would be fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108499048&userid=983261&signature=3M2Nw9c8mvTj0Yu3pV06mg
any help is appreciated, thank you:)

The sushi cat is originally from a 2010 litter. 2021 stores are worth at least 35c$ IMO which is somewhere around a 2010 rare, so this is a fair offer if you like the pet

[whitediamonds]

Any opinions would be appreciated!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108498108&userid=283615&signature=1NwABSY1-aGqDTCq685ImA

[birdiesong]

Any opinions would be appreciated!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108498108&userid=283615&signature=1NwABSY1-aGqDTCq685ImA

this is unfair to you. the 2021 store pet rat is worth around a 2010 rare, which their side doesn’t add up to.

[Candilicious]

Hi again. I got this trade and was wondering if it was fair?

[Kassit]

Hi! Would be very appreciative of any assistance.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108481966&userid=736471&signature=7kuP_7vxombgdrqVXcBbkA

[Clayflower.]

Hi again. I got this trade and was wondering if it was fair?

hello! they're overpaying datewise and since it's the same rarity they're overpaying by a decent amount; plus the extra deer!