The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108596205&userid=70359&signature=0MTAWeaUBbRrpAKNSKmVYg Is this a fair offer. I am genuinely curious and want to be sure if accepting this is fair or not.

Depending on how you value C$ (differently people value it differently, I believe this is more than fair for that date and rarity. BUT the fixes on your side have excellent demand, and can go for quite a lot of overpay. That’s something to keep in mind.

How much are these items worth? Seems like overpay from the other side? Or am I super off on item value?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108593290&userid=212847&signature=Mf0SAJgwLM90cyEOmpn7nQ

Similar answer to above. Unfair to them by date and (approximate) rarity. However, because there were so many different fish released, and since they were token trade ins, they tend to be pretty hard to find. I don’t know their exact demand since mine aren’t for trade, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they can go for more than their expected value.

[shoob]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108589440&userid=1078676&signature=HXf13-v2sAX4Dfe6YEbpyQ
opinions on this?

[Magpiejay]

I just got this trade and would love help!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108589620&userid=793299&signature=10kCI2YKnNjl6GVrvImRyg

I would love some help please

could I get a second opinion on this

[Pinkapillar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108602883&userid=318027&signature=0X8Y1XsqBmGEB6QGJbxsWQ
i'd love some advice!

[captxin]

how abt this one? I’ve gotten 2 offers for the zebra today,, and I have no idea the worth

[LionKingdom]

Small trade but the dates confuse me and stuff, dunno if this is fair bc idk malk demand

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108594142&userid=925400&signature=dGI1vCyE7u57ac07f5R_Zw

[whitediamonds]

Thoughts on this please? Also, their pet is named "1 MA" but I don't recognize it?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108604747&userid=283615&signature=RZ-x6S2imPuEH1ONTw2-zg

[keayi]

Thoughts on this please? Also, their pet is named "1 MA" but I don't recognize it?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108604747&userid=283615&signature=RZ-x6S2imPuEH1ONTw2-zg

I found it under the "regular 2009 very rares" in Horror's guide (B&W Husky), and it's not an ex-list so it's technically not a Main Advent. It is a new ER however so I would still value it between 2-4 2009 rares (If 1 ER = 2 VR = 4 R), which is 0,5 MA.

Realistic dog breeds trade anywhere between 0,5-1 MA, so I would probably lean to unfair to you.

Small trade but the dates confuse me and stuff, dunno if this is fair bc idk malk demand

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108594142&userid=925400&signature=dGI1vCyE7u57ac07f5R_Zw

I think it's fine to set aside dates most of the time, but 2013 to 2019 is a 6 year gap which is quite a bit... I'd probably ask for a couple 2012ish uncommons just in case.

how abt this one? I’ve gotten 2 offers for the zebra today,, and I have no idea the worth

Zebras are worth 0,75-1 NON and remain some of the rarest pets on the site.. So roughly 8-12 MA (~50-100 '09 R)

The Blue Anniversary dog is a former "regular VR" so it was worth 2 '09 R. It's a new ER so I would probably value it at 2-4 '09 R (which is 0,5 MA). The Mustard Husky is an ex-Main Advent (1 MA). Although it is a new OMGSR, I would greatly advise against this trade as by demand it seems unfair to you by at least 6,5 MAs.

[Jimmy_]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108605598&userid=1050817&signature=aI_odtg0maGxMwknWwjrOA Its fair?Thanks you in advance!
Sorry! I hope the trade shows up now!

[Ashki]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108605598 Its fair?Thanks you in advance!

We're unable to view your trade - make sure to use the shareable trade link at the bottom of the page!