The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[fish]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107943025&userid=551103&signature=NyeI-PGY1Zbu8s9w3DX1kA

i wonder if anyone could give me thoughts on this??

unless I’m missing something, it looks unfair to you? Your wolf is older by a year, and there’s significantly more demand for it

okay thank you! that's what i was thinking but wanted confirmation. appreciate it!

[Lizord]

Is this fair?
I haven't done any rare+ trades since the rarity update so I have no idea owo

[WinterBoba]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108227766&userid=1048601&signature=gjSq_3v5-mMZvDobDzFUEw
Is this fair?

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108174437&userid=881679&signature=5PJ9T9c_oJQkaYBgW8QHNw

any help with this trade is greatly appreciated!!

[chase.]

Is this fair?
I haven't done any rare+ trades since the rarity update so I have no idea owo

i would advise getting a second opinion, just because I’m not 100% confident with the rarity update

your deer storepet is with 1ma, their blue shadow cat is 1ma, so I’m pretty sure they’re a fair trade alone? so I would guess that the person is overpaying with the additional rares?
I don’t know if their worth has been changed because of the update, but i had a look for an answer to that and it seems no one’s quite sure what to make of it, so I think they’re still equivalent?

[gh0stboy]

bad at item values so i would like to get some opinions!

one
two
three

[ZozoJesterz]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108228917&userid=896768&signature=9896fXez4_rJ3P8yzaOCow

nothing majorly rare, but is this fair? thank you in advance <3

[chase.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108228917&userid=896768&signature=9896fXez4_rJ3P8yzaOCow

nothing majorly rare, but is this fair? thank you in advance <3

this is really unfair to you, unless I’ve missed something ^^
your pets are older and extremely uncommon/uncommon, whereas there’s aren’t. I don’t know what the growing outcomes on their side would be, but I really doubt they’d make this trade fair even if they turned out to be uncommon

[Checkinder]

Thoughts on this trade?

[ZozoJesterz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108228917&userid=896768&signature=9896fXez4_rJ3P8yzaOCow

nothing majorly rare, but is this fair? thank you in advance <3

this is really unfair to you, unless I’ve missed something ^^
your pets are older and extremely uncommon/uncommon, whereas there’s aren’t. I don’t know what the growing outcomes on their side would be, but I really doubt they’d make this trade fair even if they turned out to be uncommon

ah I see, the unknown ratities confused me lol. thank you!!