The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[musicgurl333]

The mixed dates on this one are throwing me off. Their rare is a year older than mine and the others are a year younger and more common so I can see it being unfair either way. I'd really appreciate outside opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137075&userid=283615&signature=sHD_Bv3T0_-7IQX1rmq8Uw

Would still really appreciate any feedback on the above trade, and now this one:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108187623&userid=283615&signature=w7bZEWyKPrN62L8fgCBZ8w

I really don't know what's fair when it comes to trading pets from different years and how many newer pets are worth older ones.


And this third one:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108181174&userid=283615&signature=y-RmBKhZmErM7FXo7qcapA

I'm pretty sure it's unfair due to date/rarity but just double checking in case I missed something.

Honestly, it kind of depends. Before the rarity update, a lot of people used the "2:1 rule", so it would take 2 '14 rares to equal 1 '15 rare. Personally, I always thought that was ridiculous and I think it's even worse now. Some people have proposed a "three year rule" where pets within 3 years can swap evenly. That makes a lot more sense to me!

Using that method, the first trade would be unfair to you because all pets are close enough to swap, but your cat is a higher rarity than their their deer.

Using the "3 year rule" the second trade is unfair to them. The higher rarity, plus the extra pets and items, are more than enough to make up for the 4 year gap.

Third one is DEFINITELY unfair to you. They're not offering nearly enough quantity to make up for the gaps in date AND rarity.

Could I have some advice on this, please? I’ve never been asked for this many of my pets before, so I’m feeling super hesitant to accept it

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108186965&userid=1004201&signature=w-sAasEq7uaf9kYpxKNXZw

Absolutely EXTREMELY unfair to you. They're asking for a LOT more quantity, a lot of the pets are more rare than theirs, and a most of your pets are older. The only pet they're offering that's older is the '15 dragon, and that's just a common that doesn't have any special demand that would make it worth NEARLY that much.

[tanjirou]

I'm wondering if this is fair to the other person? I have four 2022 store dogs and they're asking me to choose two of the rats, since they are 2011 rares.

is this a fair trade?

still need a second opinion!

[StarryWish.]

I'm doing an Auction that ends today & I'd love help on what each trade is worth... The auction is for a TD Yellowfang. Thank you in advance for the help!!!

Yellowfang Auction
* Bid #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107553502&userid=1064234&signature=6qWuC5Ri8cZrL_y7_hvaWQ

* Bid #2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107946882&userid=1064234&signature=gX7IpAedQeQOnSi2Kw6uTA

* Bid #3 (I think this is the the best offer.)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108129056&userid=1064234&signature=PhMyfMLwmgiDqZf_iCAE-A

I'd love a second opinion please!

i agree with the first opinion. the third is the best imo, but it really does come down to your preference. both are bulk but horse and pony pets are low demand

[musicgurl333]

I'm wondering if this is fair to the other person? I have four 2022 store dogs and they're asking me to choose two of the rats, since they are 2011 rares.

is this a fair trade?

still need a second opinion!

It depends on how you value store pets. Current store pets are worth an ‘11 rare. Personally, I don’t agree with that, and I think it under values them. They want to edit to FOUR ‘23 store pets for only 2 ‘11 rares? If so, that’s quite unfair to you. Plus, they’re rats, which are hard to trade off and very low demand. I personally wouldn’t accept the current trade if I were you, but it is about “fair” by current trading standards, ignoring demand. But I would ABSOLUTELY NOT trade your four store pets for just two of the rats.

[Ashki]

I'm wondering if this is fair to the other person? I have four 2022 store dogs and they're asking me to choose two of the rats, since they are 2011 rares.

is this a fair trade?

still need a second opinion!

It depends on how you value store pets. Current store pets are worth an ‘11 rare. Personally, I don’t agree with that, and I think it under values them. They want to edit to FOUR ‘23 store pets for only 2 ‘11 rares? If so, that’s quite unfair to you. Plus, they’re rats, which are hard to trade off and very low demand. I personally wouldn’t accept the current trade if I were you, but it is about “fair” by current trading standards, ignoring demand. But I would ABSOLUTELY NOT trade your four store pets for just two of the rats.

Agreed on this!

[DarkNights]

help with this?

[lucifer morningstar]

hoping for some advice on an item trade, here. based on my research the wizard token is worth 0.25n-0.5n, but I'm not entirely sure how much their side adds up to total. any input would be greatly appreciated! c:
lucifer

[Axuwu]

Absolutely EXTREMELY unfair to you. They're asking for a LOT more quantity, a lot of the pets are more rare than theirs, and a most of your pets are older. The only pet they're offering that's older is the '15 dragon, and that's just a common that doesn't have any special demand that would make it worth NEARLY that much.

Thank you so much for the advice, I really appreciate it!! Have an amazing day! :D

[Zeblua]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108193935&userid=184784&signature=-aoku-foae5xxV2LOSJWaw
Can someone please let me know if this is fair? If I keep accepting their trades, they'll keep sending and I need to know if I'm being ripped off or not. Not that I suspect they are, just that I never took the time to learn what things are worth!

[raniasolo]

Hello, does anyone know if these trades are fair?
Trade 1
Trade 2

Any help would be appreciated, thank you in advance.