The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EspressoCat]

Is my Trade for my Dream Pets Fair? Idk cause they said they only want Pets of the same year unless it's A few years behind the year they were made, If it's not fair then I have to edit trade and remove some pets. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108180140&userid=1090345&signature=_xEp9kg_HObXO5Nx6PG_qw

[방탄소년단]

Can I have some opinions on this?

someone can correct me if i am wrong, and i hope this makes sense, but:

ur bee = 3 nons

seal pps set = 2.25 nons
x4 carousel horse = 2 MA each - total 8 MA
x4 alien dogs = 1 MA each - total 4 MA

altogether 12 MA
10-12 MA = 1 non

so their side = 3 nons
your side = 3.25 nons

i'm not really sure what demand is like for the ur bee, so i can't really give my opinion on that side of things

[GroveSabertooth]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108166672&userid=110431&signature=D28fNWGYBdWdRXRjbAGRsQ

any opinions on this? tysm in advance. Not sure what the demand for the UR apple has been lately

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108174437&userid=881679&signature=5PJ9T9c_oJQkaYBgW8QHNw

any help with this trade is greatly appreciated!!

[cats135]

Can I have some opinions on this?

someone can correct me if i am wrong, and i hope this makes sense, but:

ur bee = 3 nons

seal pps set = 2.25 nons
x4 carousel horse = 2 MA each - total 8 MA
x4 alien dogs = 1 MA each - total 4 MA

altogether 12 MA
10-12 MA = 1 non

so their side = 3 nons
your side = 3.25 nons

i'm not really sure what demand is like for the ur bee, so i can't really give my opinion on that side of things

Quoting a friend, also consider how the UR Bee can be rereleased, and the store pets not, giving them more rarity overall, which I'd say makes the trade Very unfair to you.

[Vampie!]

Does this look fair?

[ButterflyChaser]

How does this sound? I like the pets offered,but I'm not sure if I should hold off on trading my Nick pets for them.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108062110&userid=30121&signature=KdQqp-gjPVWv97vwD8-fnw

This is unfair to you. Some of their offerings are rare store pets (?) or at least not necessarily desired, and the nick unicorn is pretty desired on CS. The nick unicorn is a 2008 re-release.

Edit: correction— the two rare dogs were summer event pets from 2013.

It is not the unicorn. I wish I had one though.

[FlightFeathers]

No idea what the Malk elementals are worth
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=108179794&userid=932354&signature=nAc9tOuMYxeZa9LuGzLWEA

[Axuwu]

Could I have some advice on this, please? I’ve never been asked for this many of my pets before, so I’m feeling super hesitant to accept it

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108186965&userid=1004201&signature=w-sAasEq7uaf9kYpxKNXZw

[whitediamonds]

The mixed dates on this one are throwing me off. Their rare is a year older than mine and the others are a year younger and more common so I can see it being unfair either way. I'd really appreciate outside opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137075&userid=283615&signature=sHD_Bv3T0_-7IQX1rmq8Uw

Would still really appreciate any feedback on the above trade, and now this one:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108187623&userid=283615&signature=w7bZEWyKPrN62L8fgCBZ8w

I really don't know what's fair when it comes to trading pets from different years and how many newer pets are worth older ones.


And this third one:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108181174&userid=283615&signature=y-RmBKhZmErM7FXo7qcapA

I'm pretty sure it's unfair due to date/rarity but just double checking in case I missed something.