The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lluca]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108126670&userid=273739&signature=2tuOaSoHbD0X90Ea9Rwaig

[tuxam]

i'm not very good with item values. would this be fair?

[ButterflyChaser]

How does this sound? I like the pets offered,but I'm not sure if I should hold off on trading my Nick pets for them.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108062110&userid=30121&signature=KdQqp-gjPVWv97vwD8-fnw

[Cerberussi]

i'm not very good with item values. would this be fair?

a general rule for items is that theyre usually worth an uncommon of the year they were released, with exceptions for popularity, event, or age.

this is super unfair to you imo.

[slugg-e]

How does this sound? I like the pets offered,but I'm not sure if I should hold off on trading my Nick pets for them.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108062110&userid=30121&signature=KdQqp-gjPVWv97vwD8-fnw

This is unfair to you. Some of their offerings are rare store pets (?) or at least not necessarily desired, and the nick unicorn is pretty desired on CS. The nick unicorn is a 2008 re-release.

Edit: correction— the two rare dogs were summer event pets from 2013.

[Xanpoon]

Does this look okay?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108154341&userid=725734&signature=IcU2R58R0q_mRxSmCXCxgA

[Electric~Lime~Zebra]

Does this look okay?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108154341&userid=725734&signature=IcU2R58R0q_mRxSmCXCxgA

I think this is really unfair to you. According to this guide. A 2012 uc has been valued roughly around 7-9 C$ alone. Even though C$ prices can change depending on person to person and some with recent rarity changes (regardless the 12 UC or 12 EUC should be close to the same value in this guide ), you should be able to narrow it down pretty close to what most users would pay for it.

[whitediamonds]

The mixed dates on this one are throwing me off. Their rare is a year older than mine and the others are a year younger and more common so I can see it being unfair either way. I'd really appreciate outside opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108137075&userid=283615&signature=sHD_Bv3T0_-7IQX1rmq8Uw

[Merlinslair]

Fair? I tried doing it myself for the first time so I want to check xD

.5ma Is around 4 09 rare n’ dragons from what I just researched are around 2 09 rare each which would add up to the .5ma is this right?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108155049&userid=659383&signature=2HgKpswFbNPO-D31jd5kcw

[StarryWish.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108155868&userid=651644&signature=K-2xhjUu-5tu8nS-cLosUw
fair to me?