The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[birdiesong]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108126031&userid=273739&signature=4bKHx5hjwLJ8NAsjgTw74w

i’d say this is unfair to you. the deer store pet would be a good swap for the snake store pet alone. store pet rarities are a lil weird, but even though the deer is a very rare it’s not worth significantly more than the snake store pet which is only a rare. all the extra snakes makes it overpay on your side.

maybe just the snake store pet plus one of the normal snake rares would be a good compromise to make up for the deer being a few months older.

[Lluca]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108126031&userid=273739&signature=4bKHx5hjwLJ8NAsjgTw74w

i’d say this is unfair to you. the deer store pet would be a good swap for the snake store pet alone. store pet rarities are a lil weird, but even though the deer is a very rare it’s not worth significantly more than the snake store pet which is only a rare. all the extra snakes makes it overpay on your side.

maybe just the snake store pet plus one of the normal snake rares would be a good compromise to make up for the deer being a few months older.

Thank you for the fast reply!

Got a new trade from the same person.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108126670&userid=273739&signature=2tuOaSoHbD0X90Ea9Rwaig - How does this look?

[Ruruskadoo]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

[Sakkiel]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

Not really good at values but this looks really unfair to them, but hoarders often overpay so i think it's an assumed overpay?

[ryland]

Hey there c:
I’m looking for some advice when it comes to this and this.
Any/all help is appreciated. Thank you in advance!

**Edit: this too if possible.

[Solloby]

Thank you for answering my question earlier Heather Ale <3

Hey there c:
I’m looking for some advice when it comes to this and this.
Any/all help is appreciated. Thank you in advance!

**Edit: this too if possible.

For that first trade, your puppy is a rereleased Oct 2008 dog. The trade looks unfair to you, but I'm not particularly familiar with their VR butterfly wolf so I'm unsure why they've asked for so much. Maybe seek a second opinion to check there's nothing I've missed here.

For your second trade, under the current non/ma system a quick search of the pets involved suggests that both sides are worth about "1.5 nons". I have not traded any of those pets recently, so definitely get a second opinion about that one. Those pets are very valuable and I don't know if any are particularly sought after more than others.

That third trade is hard because I don't think the trading community expected Boar PPS to go OMGSR. So I don't think there's much confidence in the community about its value, and I've seen that 2013 store pet going for a fairly wide variety of values as well. So it's very hard to work out what the top side of that trade is. I can't really tell you if it's fair or not sorry.

[ryland]

Thank you so much ^^

[Painful Affinity]

Uh, so i got this suggestion and the person wants me to edit but uh..i don't know what to do. At all. What would i have to change?

Thank you in advance <3

Nevermind it got cancelled

[- Alice -]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

[leachface]

I am 99.9% sure this is unfair to me but can I just get an opinion real quick?; doot

All I’m certain is I can recall people auctioning Pocky items about a year or so back. And they can go for older rares.
Items I believe do not get re-released, minus the items that remain indefinitely in store.
I’d personally say unfair to you, but make sure to get a second opinion