The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[CrystalCadaver]

Wanting to send a trade offer of one of my rare pets for some pets from someone else but I don't know what would be fair.

I haven't sent the trade yet, but I'm offering this

For these

First four pets I'm asking for are 2022 pets, fifth is a 2023 pet. Mine is a rare from the camping event this year. I don't know if this is unfair for me, or unfair for them. I'm still trying to wrap my head around the trading system. Any help/opinions are appreciated.

[JDxx]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108097190&userid=1025047&signature=vft5v-XQ5ZVczeY8qBPjdg

They offered a 2011 rare for 12 of my Halloween event pets

Would rlly like some help please!

i'd personally see it as unfair.

it depends on your perspective, but for me:

altogether, the pets they are trading for cost 37 event tokens (if i counted correctly)
on average, people are selling event tokens for 3 c$ each, so going off that, 37 event tokens = 111 c$
a 2011 rare is worth around 30 c$

Thanks for the help, appreciate it

But if I look to another guide it says 2023 rares are worth 1-3C$, and assuming they are all rares.

Using tokens or the guide are both pretty reliable but have big differences, so which method should I use?

[Ruruskadoo]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

[ajz]

Hi, I'm still learning about fair trades and all.
Considering the dates as well, is this fair?:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108122052&userid=433642&signature=05MhuC2DqPkjY8XS8J_j1g

[CarpetShark]

Are any of these fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108056245&userid=304899&signature=GazzBN3KlJ_1r-ZqIfJymw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108066442&userid=304899&signature=GpGPf-E_G10Z5ocoD_SLBg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108091058&userid=304899&signature=c3TI3mNhs_ZQhdK5XJmL2w

Thanks in advance!

[Ashki]

Are any of these fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108056245&userid=304899&signature=GazzBN3KlJ_1r-ZqIfJymw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108066442&userid=304899&signature=GpGPf-E_G10Z5ocoD_SLBg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108091058&userid=304899&signature=c3TI3mNhs_ZQhdK5XJmL2w

Thanks in advance!

1. I'd say unfair to you. With the new rarity update things may have changed a bit, but I still tend to see people using the 2:1 system when it goes for 09 and '10 rares, so their side would add up to 1 09 rare. This may be different depending on how you value them though! Also, ponies tend to have lower demand than dogs.

2. Unfair to you, that store pet goes for .5 MA or 3-4 09 rares.

3. Unfair to you, for similar reasons to #1. Their side would be unfair for even one of those pets in my opinion, their side would add up to a bit more than 1 09 rare + 1 '10 rare.

[Vampie!]

Hey, does this look ok?

[^~^LePanda^~^]

Hey, does this look ok?

Their side is way over year wise but if it’s about sentiment totally up to you

[Ashki]

Hey, does this look ok?

Their side is way over year wise but if it’s about sentiment totally up to you

The bird is a store pet that goes for a 2011 rare - I'd say unfair to you.

[Lluca]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108126031&userid=273739&signature=4bKHx5hjwLJ8NAsjgTw74w