The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Dawni]

Anyone with some experience trading items for pets able to give me some advice on whether this Trade is fair?

to my knowledge, none of the items on your side are particularly old or valuable and i believe are only free items from the last few years, so they definitely would not equal to the malk pps horse alone. overpay on their end.

Thanks for the help!

[JDxx]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108097190&userid=1025047&signature=vft5v-XQ5ZVczeY8qBPjdg

They offered a 2011 rare for 12 of my Halloween event pets

Would rlly like some help please!

[Ruruskadoo]

EDIT: Thanks Ashki for the advice on the other trades!

Can anyone tell me if this last one is fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

[Heather Ale]

Need more item trade help
I’m happy about the offer, but I have no idea about what items go for. Opinions?

imo no, i’m not sure what the going rate is for the terrarium and stars are but they’re asking for a lot of older items that are in good demand from what i’ve seen. but second opinion would def help

Thank you!
What would be fair to ask for?

[방탄소년단]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108097190&userid=1025047&signature=vft5v-XQ5ZVczeY8qBPjdg

They offered a 2011 rare for 12 of my Halloween event pets

Would rlly like some help please!

i'd personally see it as unfair.

it depends on your perspective, but for me:

altogether, the pets they are trading for cost 37 event tokens (if i counted correctly)
on average, people are selling event tokens for 3 c$ each, so going off that, 37 event tokens = 111 c$
a 2011 rare is worth around 30 c$

[Ashki]

Are these fair?

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108052692&userid=119355&signature=olWfaZcMyc4_vEm00-vdDQ

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108065505&userid=119355&signature=M7f5oD9Luilb-NGvJYxsMA

3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108065427&userid=119355&signature=O-tZT5EPXA5T8wcQ8QvxgA

4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=108090473&userid=119355&signature=mOyc63ULeQdfs53conRpxg

Not certain about 1, but I'd say 2 is definitely unfair to you. 3 can't be for sure because of the unknown rarities - the uncommon and very uncommon pets are fair rarity swaps though. 4 I'd say is unfair to you.

[StarryWish.]

Thank you!
What would be fair to ask for?

i’d say at least 4/5 rares from the items years or equivalent in c$. not exactly sure what the slumber party items fetch in c$ now

[AuroraFier]

I have zero knowledge of what pets are worth in C$. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108097796&userid=1064234&signature=c1wYD1TaIF0xKvQVeZGldA

Thank you!!

[heartfades]

I have zero knowledge of what pets are worth in C$. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=108097796&userid=1064234&signature=c1wYD1TaIF0xKvQVeZGldA

Thank you!!

overpay on their part what they gave was worth more than the c$ imo

[raniasolo]

Hello, is this fair? any help would be appreciated.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107720216&userid=831492&signature=4BBFE-vGVlBbh2q0flo6HQ

Thank you in Advance.

Edit: also this one aswell