The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107835539&userid=1039839&signature=eg1imepOm6v95DOFmO7PbQ
need a second opinion on this one if possible! thank you <3

They're both worth 0,5 MA (Ravenpaw, Manticore) so this would be pretty fair. Both have consistently good demand so you should not have trouble trading off either in the future

here

not sure at all -- not fond of rat and am willing to let go, but I am not well adversed in list rarities

here as well!

1) Seems slightly under for a TD OMGSR rat, but maybe the cookie advent will be worth more since it's a new OMGSR

TD Green Tinsel Dog = 1 MA
Cookie Advent = 1 MA
TD Light Speckled Rat = 0,25-0,5 NON = 3-5 MA

2) The rerelease Bobtail is from 2008 and I thiiink it's treated as a extended release so it trades as a 2009 pet also? It's swappable with their pet so I don't see the need for you to also trade off the 2015 UC and 2018 R unless you really want that pet

[Raven Bird]

Could someone help me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107944889&userid=49692&signature=UCZ6u2rjS0k28pEwnTrxdQ

I'm entirely unsure if this is fair!

*also I hope the names are changed, when I click the link it says both trading parties!

I still need help if anyone is able! Thank you, I don't really understand the guide.

[keayi]

Could someone help me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107944889&userid=49692&signature=UCZ6u2rjS0k28pEwnTrxdQ

I'm entirely unsure if this is fair!

*also I hope the names are changed, when I click the link it says both trading parties!

I still need help if anyone is able! Thank you, I don't really understand the guide.

The two 2009 very rares are swappable. You'd be overpaying with the 2011 rares.

[skyereon]

Hi folks! I was recently offered 31 '20-'23 rares and 9 items for a 2009 malk dog.

Trade: trades/viewtrade.php?id=107949044&userid=2346&signature=ifBQNF7_iMR2vjdUX6Fr6Q

I am not sure how to value the malk dog, so I am not sure if the volume of newer 'rare' tier pets is a fair swap for a 2009 'extremely rare' tier pet.

If anyone could advise me, I would really appreciate it! ^^ Thank you in advance for your time.

[Raven Bird]

Could someone help me?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107944889&userid=49692&signature=UCZ6u2rjS0k28pEwnTrxdQ

I'm entirely unsure if this is fair!

*also I hope the names are changed, when I click the link it says both trading parties!

I still need help if anyone is able! Thank you, I don't really understand the guide.

The two 2009 very rares are swappable. You'd be overpaying with the 2011 rares.

Thanks so much!

[ryland]

Need help with this. Thanks in advance

[answrs]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107945616&userid=2710&signature=zn9WFqfBU0PIJYbndaajeA
going by these value posts:
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4829408&p=142188106&hilit=egg#p142188106
and https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4829408&p=142613740&hilit=egg#p142613740
plus the Vampiric being at the top of the high very rare just below the egg's low e rare

I'm pretty sure the store is too much, is the dog and lion together also too much, or relatively equal?

[AuroraFier]

Can I please get some help with these. Thank you!

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107908294&userid=1064234&signature=WRqbccDa9nrms-D5l8aVOQ

Also wondering about these auction bids...

Bid #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107553502&userid=1064234&signature=6qWuC5Ri8cZrL_y7_hvaWQ

Bid #2
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107926461&userid=1064234&signature=AM8NqRB0b0ytC9oCACDGUA

Bid #3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107946882&userid=1064234&signature=gX7IpAedQeQOnSi2Kw6uTA

Thank you in advance for any help!!!

[MoonDriveZee]

Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107925578&userid=699834&signature=ujfjq8_NHcRyRlqI_usKrg

[skyereon]

Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107925578&userid=699834&signature=ujfjq8_NHcRyRlqI_usKrg

I am not a trading expert, but that seems super unbalanced in their favor to me. They are only offering three more recent pets, one being a touch higher but mostly comparable rarity, in exchange for a bunch of your older rares. I do not think you should accept it as is; my understanding is that release date of pets is also worth considering, and all/most of yours are much older.