The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[w i l d.]

Just a question: is it fair to trade my 2020 store pet (very rare & shown below) for 40c$?

[Sealipup]

Hi, could I get advice on this trade please? Mostly the store dog, I don't know how to find out its worth ;o;

[keayi]

Hi, could I get advice on this trade please? Mostly the store dog, I don't know how to find out its worth ;o;

You can check Horror's old guide here (I think it's getting revised soon) and the successful trades thread. They're overpaying because the store Phoenix Dog and the Border Collie are worth the same

Phoenix Dog = 1 MA
Gray Border Collie = 1 MA (Former advent)

Just a question: is it fair to trade my 2020 store pet (very rare & shown below) for 40c$?

Roughly, yes that is what they're worth. I recently traded a 2020 store for 45c$ and a 2019 store for 55c$

[Overnight]

Could I get advice on this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107904830&userid=496745&signature=xYj2Seq7kDphBvtyBRs2PA

[Magpiejay]

Is this fair?
my omgsr orange for this?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107945623&userid=793299&signature=2w_0T9idKwHOZBtrcJz7jg

[Sealipup]

Hi, could I get advice on this trade please? Mostly the store dog, I don't know how to find out its worth ;o;

You can check Horror's old guide here (I think it's getting revised soon) and the successful trades thread. They're overpaying because the store Phoenix Dog and the Border Collie are worth the same

Phoenix Dog = 1 MA
Gray Border Collie = 1 MA (Former advent)

Thank you so much for this! I was looking at the guide I just didn't know it was called a phoenix dog haha, my mistake

[Evil Corruption]

Hi, it's the new player again. 😅 I got a trade for my red caterpillar and Candycorn hamster from the Halloween event, here and wasn't sure if I should accept it or not? I'm missing the banner cocoon so I'm unsure if I'd want to trade it until I get the cocoon or not.

And another one here

Still need help please and thank you

[w i l d.]

-snip-
Roughly, yes that is what they're worth. I recently traded a 2020 store for 45c$ and a 2019 store for 55c$

Alright, thank you very much!

[nyanyan.com]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107935739&userid=833630&signature=w1ZsYYtSGDFw54WpruYNrw

is this fair? thank you in advance for any insight about this! <3

[soccerali9]

Would appreciate any thoughts on this trade - highest rarity involved is rare.