The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Suave]

Hi I know this thread is very overrun but if anyone could offer their opinion on this, I'm trying to trade someone for my dreamie

Thank you!

[Vampie!]

Does this trade look ok? If not, what needs to be added?
This as well?

[MoonDriveZee]

Thank you in advance!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107925578&userid=699834&signature=ujfjq8_NHcRyRlqI_usKrg

[Checkinder]

Could I have some input on this? Not sure what the demand on this dude is like anymore-

[I'm tired]

this is interesting I need help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107912077&userid=1084775&signature=OkZssJ9u7wXl3vEx9Rg1eA

[I'm tired]

Could I have some input on this? Not sure what the demand on this dude is like anymore-

unfair to you!!!

[Tumblr.]

this is interesting I need help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107912077&userid=1084775&signature=OkZssJ9u7wXl3vEx9Rg1eA

This trade is very very over on their side, as the bat will be nowhere near as rare as the pet they are offering. The dog is an old rare, and the bat is simply a good bat outcome from the free cages. at most, it will be very uncommon as the free pets have never really gone rare after events, so it is way way over on their side. Even if the bat did go rare, it would still be extremely over! Hope that helps!

[SoFancyCake]

this is interesting I need help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107912077&userid=1084775&signature=OkZssJ9u7wXl3vEx9Rg1eA

They’re overpaying for the bat pretty clearly. Id like to also take this time and ask that you please consider not giving additional advice to people asking on the tread. Your responses haven’t been the most accurate or descriptive.

[Tumblr.]

Could I have some input on this? Not sure what the demand on this dude is like anymore-

To just give a slightly more detailed answer, while agreeing with the statement it is unfair to you, i figured i would explain why it is unfair!

The Arabian horses on your side are 3/4 of the omgsr store horses you are offering them. they are worth .25-.5 non but generally were traded at closer to .25n before the update, but due to the rarity jump i would assume them to likely begin to be traded closer to the .5N mark.
The single Clydesdale on your side, the remaining horse, is worth .5n solid before the update and is expected to remain at that price, even after the rarity jump; just with a slight increase in demand from what i can assume.
The forest guardians on your side, sat at a solid 2Ma before the update, and have traded at that price consistently for a good while so i do not see them changing because of the update, but the demand did seem to raise due to the rarity increase.

Thair dog, The BA has really decent demand. However, it did not go up to Omgsr with the rarity update and due to that it's demand has taken a very small hit. It stayed at a solid 1 non for a very long time, and only TD ones have gone for anything higher. No new trades since the rarity update have been posted on the successful trades thread so it's assumed to remain at 1non solid.

So ill give both the high end and the low in rates for the trade now:

Low end;
(your side)
.25n x3 = .75n
.5 n
4Ma/ high end of .25n
= 1.5Non so you would be over paying

High end:
(your side/ Not accounting for the Clydesdale changing any value)
.5n x 4 = 2n
4Ma/ high end of .25n
= 2.25Non so you would be extremely overpaying.

Hope this helps explain it just a little more! This is the best i can say with the rarity update shaking things up so much, but i hope it helps you understand a little better!

(Refrences pulled from Horror's pre-update list referring to the " Arabians/Clydesdale ('11)" and "Forest Guardians ('11)" )

[I'm tired]

this is interesting I need help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107912077&userid=1084775&signature=OkZssJ9u7wXl3vEx9Rg1eA

This trade is very very over on their side, as the bat will be nowhere near as rare as the pet they are offering. The dog is an old rare, and the bat is simply a good bat outcome from the free cages. at most, it will be very uncommon as the free pets have never really gone rare after events, so it is way way over on their side. Even if the bat did go rare, it would still be extremely over! Hope that helps!

TYSM!!