The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[marmoris]

could i get some help w this one??
thank you in advance <3

[Androys]

Tough to tell if these are fair:/

- Trade #1

- Trade #2

[Clayflower.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107889996&userid=1088985&signature=S4_kIK0PySWSCGwmJ6LC1g

does the sitting cat have any special demand?

hi uta!! yes!! your cat is known as a "warrior cat". that particular one is "Jayfeather". they're from the popular book series Warrior Cats by Erin Hunter. I personally wouldn't take this trade! They're always sought after.

[uta1911]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107889996&userid=1088985&signature=S4_kIK0PySWSCGwmJ6LC1g

does the sitting cat have any special demand?

hi uta!! yes!! your cat is known as a "warrior cat". that particular one is "Jayfeather". they're from the popular book series Warrior Cats by Erin Hunter. I personally wouldn't take this trade! They're always sought after.

thank you! i knew some did and some didnt, cant ever tell LOL

[Wired]

Just not sure about this one. I paid 650 C$ for the dog, so I’m mostly tentative because of that
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107886871&userid=542359&signature=KVW2-1GqYihZgWagQHLjOQ

[smartiez]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107891160&userid=825583&signature=QkIzxXIpG96vVWSjQnTCqw I would rather not have a rat, but thoughts and opinions? I also do not recall the year of the dog -- please let me know!

Also, unrelated; how do I put text in place of a URL? Thnks x

[Clayflower.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107891160&userid=825583&signature=QkIzxXIpG96vVWSjQnTCqw I would rather not have a rat, but thoughts and opinions? I also do not recall the year of the dog -- please let me know!

Also, unrelated; how do I put text in place of a URL? Thnks x

hiii :) your dog is a RR; originally from August of 2008. Given they're the same rarity and year, It's a pretty even swap. However, rats do tend to be a bit difficult trading off sometimes!

You can put text in a link like so: [url=(trade share link)]any text you want[/url]

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=107891160&userid=825583&signature=QkIzxXIpG96vVWSjQnTCqw I would rather not have a rat, but thoughts and opinions? I also do not recall the year of the dog -- please let me know!

Also, unrelated; how do I put text in place of a URL? Thnks x

hiii your dog is a RR; originally from August of 2008. Given they're the same rarity and year, It's a pretty even swap. However, rats do tend to be a bit difficult trading off sometimes!

You can put text in a link like so: [url=(trade share link)]any text you want[/url]

Just wanted to add that the dog is an extended release that was available for a year. Because of that, it’s valued as an ‘09 rare, not an ‘08 one. Although rats don’t have great demand, there’s not much demand for this dog either. Plus, the rat is a true date and the dog is a rerelease, which SHOULDN’T make a difference, but a lot of people prefer true date pets. Unfair to the rat.

[Lilbit]

Hi! I'm not brushed up on my item rarities at all, does anyone know if this is fair? ^-^

[strwberry]

any help is appreciated!:)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107693486&userid=983261&signature=BF89BKTAdY83VYEEdnYafw