The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LeFluer]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107291445&userid=839334&signature=aD-O7HhBjTvP-JpliOvcmw

Still looking for help with this

[SoccerKat27]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107291447&userid=147876&signature=wHHwQ303Gb6lTDyb2ppK1g

Still wanna know about this green bat dog trade!

[Ruruskadoo]

Fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107292762&userid=119355&signature=gMAlLdpYdeDHu3RhZ_xFdQ

[stormsurge0]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=107202965&userid=887698&signature=guXg-7d2j_PpPGhidr8DiA

(Tysm to the person who helped with the other two) Any thoughts on this, considering demand too?

[musicgurl333]

Would this trade be fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

I have been asking for days now. Any help is appreciated!

[nasa]

still seeking a 2nd opinion for these. thanks in advance!
1
2

[rey skywalker]

Would this trade be fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

I have been asking for days now. Any help is appreciated!

I persoally feel they are overpaying for older store pets. But it's up to you. I personally would suggest they remove one of the very rares. I think its satisfied by a rainbow and a vr.

[himarry 124]

Would this trade be fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

I have been asking for days now. Any help is appreciated!

I persoally feel they are overpaying for older store pets. But it's up to you. I personally would suggest they remove one of the very rares. I think its satisfied by a rainbow and a vr.

if im not mistaken the dino's have gotten ma's for a while, so its unfair to the dinos but i would advice a third opinion

[Colormancy]

Hihi, I'm inexperienced with larger trades! Since there's a lot of value in this trade I thought it'd be worth asking if it's fair!

Trade link

Still would like help!

[AuroraFier]

Any help/advice would be greatly appreciated!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107268902&userid=1064234&signature=AMfiuJbeLToc9t9ejQs7Kw

I'm very unsure about this offer...
trades/viewtrade.php?id=107292843&userid=1064234&signature=0Qqn-YisdIxf9L2D7BCx5w

Still looking for some help. Thank you!!

Agreed that the 1st trade is unfair to you. Many of your pets are significantly older, and they have better demand. I'm not sure what exactly would needed to make it fair, though. It depends on how you value the gaps between years.

The second trade also depends on how you value dates since the rarity update. If you use the "3 year rule" that some people are adopting, then the two rares are a fair swap and the rest on their side isn't needed. If you use the old "2 year rule" for dates, then it would be unfair to you. However, that rule never really made sense even before the rarity update, and it makes less sense now.
---------------------------

Thank you so, so much for explaining everything!!! It's extremely appreciated! I'll have to think about the second trade for a bit. ^-^ Again, thank you so much for the response and explanations!!