The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GlitchyOddy]

Could I get an opinion on this? I like fish but I'm not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105946874&userid=954605&signature=lVKp0JrjKN2jHENSBDAoNw

[keayi]

Could I get an opinion on this? I like fish but I'm not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105946874&userid=954605&signature=lVKp0JrjKN2jHENSBDAoNw

This is honestly significant underpay for a 2010 rare!

[appaloosa816]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964263&userid=483044&signature=PB4D8dRLw7B9tL5CHG8eog
so i know my pet is worth 1 ma but i am not sure the value of these items on top of the old store pet with 20cs
anyone able to help?

anyone know anything?

[fennecfur]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105963209&userid=318868&signature=SY8IAtgKWxH7MlPwDwndeA

Are these pets worth the same as the tokens?

[GlitchyOddy]

Could I get an opinion on this? I like fish but I'm not sure
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105946874&userid=954605&signature=lVKp0JrjKN2jHENSBDAoNw

This is honestly significant underpay for a 2010 rare!

Thank you!!
I'm absolutely awful with values, though I thought fish were very low demand compared to staff pets so I wasn't sure if anything needed to be added or not :'>

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964263&userid=483044&signature=PB4D8dRLw7B9tL5CHG8eog
so i know my pet is worth 1 ma but i am not sure the value of these items on top of the old store pet with 20cs
anyone able to help?

Hey!
I found the terrarium set from the store (2022) to be worth ~0,5 MA total (originally 70c$ I believe? Now ~100c$, perhaps more.)
This is not the full set (see here) so I would judge this amount at roughly 25-45c$? So roughly they have 45-65c$ plus the '19 store (40-45c$) which totals 85-110c$, or around less than half a MA (if 1 MA = 250-300c$).
I'm not totally confident on this so FF to get a second opinion!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105963209&userid=318868&signature=SY8IAtgKWxH7MlPwDwndeA

Are these pets worth the same as the tokens?

No, not at all ^^" even if you traded the tokens in and got about 2-3 rare pets for them, they still wouldn't be equal to an uncommon that old.

[zophronia]

was offered this trade. i am not good with rare trades. can anyone help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964422&userid=1049101&signature=PbWaQ4fidkOCoVViAAtpcw

[keayi]

was offered this trade. i am not good with rare trades. can anyone help?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105964422&userid=1049101&signature=PbWaQ4fidkOCoVViAAtpcw

I would accept. Even if you follow +2 rule (where you add two pets of the same value for every difference in year), 1 '10 R = ~20 '22-'23 R due to the difference in release, so this is underpay (I would value each of the items at a '23 common, currently).

[Che$hire Cat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957335&userid=607005&signature=6TEe_YzXrp-GzsVdbfIFuw

Traded my store deer for the warriors, was this fair for me?

[Nocturnal Creatures]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105962187&userid=326970&signature=89IJnrdZN6yu3EgrqMHP9g

Just looking for opinions on my bid in this auction. I think my side comes to about 3-5 MA. And I know there are a few of the lions valued at 0.5 MA each. Just wondering if I should add more or not.

Thanks!!