The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[keayi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105887523&userid=1064257&signature=hH6GgSfXCizgPg43ypsktg they would be overpaying right? If the bun is worth 1 ma? Thank you to any help!♡

"Gray Spotted Bun" = 1 MA

R Warrior = 0,5 MA
plus '10 R and '11 UC

Yes, it is technically overpay on their side! All I will add is that the warrior will be much easier to trade off in the future, so upto you if you'd like to keep it

Any thoughts on this one? I'm assuming it's fair.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105911631&userid=29166&signature=9rWuFU9QJ_zTJ1k86puhYg

Rainbow drafts can technically go for 0,5 MA (at least 3-4 '09 rares) while the Osiris horse is a regular '09 VR, so it's slightly overpay on their part!

[Raptor/Nova]

any thoughts on this trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105954250&userid=1048629&signature=JrkOtjrZTi7kivJfeXxjGQ

[AuroraFier]

I'd love a second opinion on this please.

Thoughts on this? This is a trade request I've received and my first event. So I don't know if thia is a good trade... Any help would be appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105917754&userid=1064234&signature=Bkh8Si4N4lEoYYBKOGeerA

[keayi]

I'd love a second opinion on this please.

Thoughts on this? This is a trade request I've received and my first event. So I don't know if thia is a good trade... Any help would be appreciated!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105917754&userid=1064234&signature=Bkh8Si4N4lEoYYBKOGeerA

None of these are token pets (I think?) so they probably won't come out as more than UC/ea, making their side overpay just because of the difference in year alone. If it's a pet youre looking for, take it but otherwise I'd advise holding onto the event pets seeing as they're only 1 per user!

[Zylafone]

is this fair? warrior cat https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105856303&userid=783721&signature=dpxI1QuwHJghWVkPSmHRjA

bump

bump

[Toxique]

Is this fair?

[Che$hire Cat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957335&userid=607005&signature=6TEe_YzXrp-GzsVdbfIFuw

Traded my store deer for the warriors, was this fair for me?

[appaloosa816]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957857&userid=483044&signature=fLYTXjtGEfphWr5E06WvnA
i do not feel like this is fair I just need someone to explain it better for me

[mcfly,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957857&userid=483044&signature=fLYTXjtGEfphWr5E06WvnA
i do not feel like this is fair I just need someone to explain it better for me

hiya! so this is actually fair on paper, if not overpay to the store pets. each 2022 store pet is worth a 2011 rare, thus 2x 11 rares = 1 2010 rare for a 2009 spider

however, spiders can be hard to trade off so imo i would hang onto the store pets -- plus, they can grow in value (very slowly, but it happens!) i'd say it really depends on what pets you prefer but the trade technically is overpay to the store pets

[Animall]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105957857&userid=483044&signature=fLYTXjtGEfphWr5E06WvnA
i do not feel like this is fair I just need someone to explain it better for me

hiya! so this is actually fair on paper, if not overpay to the store pets. each 2022 store pet is worth a 2011 rare, thus 2x 11 rares = 1 2010 rare for a 2009 spider

however, spiders can be hard to trade off so imo i would hang onto the store pets -- plus, they can grow in value (very slowly, but it happens!) i'd say it really depends on what pets you prefer but the trade technically is overpay to the store pets

Spiders used to be hard to trade but imo Malk pets in general have great demand and are easy to trade nowadays.