The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[wolf'srain-toboe]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105341736&userid=45799&signature=y5F_5hAQf19Oaf_gc9mAtw

Need help making this fair

[Pantherpaws!! :D]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105342392&userid=1076044&signature=Yv2agYU2Z8-3SkjY3UGv_Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105339994&userid=1076044&signature=2FN1OYkOwfLNJBMeakXGbA

Please LMK if these are fair! Ty!

[spideypool]

is this a fair trade?

I only know that the April fools “UR” bwolf has fair demand, but I don’t know what it’s worth otherwise.

Still need help with this please ^-^

[BlueEyedKite]

is this a fair trade?

I only know that the April fools “UR” bwolf has fair demand, but I don’t know what it’s worth otherwise.

Still need help with this please ^-^

The rare warrior cats are .5 MA a piece x 4 is 2 MA


Black betta is a regular very rare so 2 2009 rare equivalent, the 2012 April Fool's UR Butterdog is 1 MA, the 2014 pps store pet is .5 MA. For a total of 1.5 MA + 2 2009 rares.

Unfair to the warrior cats. The betta side needs to add 1 to 2 more 2009 rare equivalent for all sides to be equal. That said, store pets have nice demand as well as malk pets so perhaps the warrior cat side won't mind the small gap?

Edit* random ted talk moment. Sometimes I don't see why certain pets aren't on the list. That black betta is a "regular 09 very rare" according to the trade guides but I could not find anyone willing to trade it for 2 2009 rares or 1 09 very rare. Canceled trades across the board. I only ended up getting it from a free trade. If I could start a list for pets to add to at least .5 MA the black betta would be on there x_x including the very rare 09 tess dragons for that matter. Thanks for listening lol

[JeffSatur'sHusband]

IS this trade fair? Please help! Thanks!
trade

[kaiserbakura]

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105343058&userid=901965&signature=aWZGzKSkYZhM16kBdr63_Q

[~Heizou~]

Is this a fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105343058&userid=901965&signature=aWZGzKSkYZhM16kBdr63_Q

A lot of overpay on your side!

[talos]

would this be a fair trade? i wanna make sure before making any decisions XD
link to trade

[BlueEyedKite]

would this be a fair trade? i wanna make sure before making any decisions XD
link to trade

I got chu

So the very rare ghost cat is worth 1 MA (I am ignoring the pride rats as we don't know their rarity)

The Dark Pointy Leopard-Spot dog is a regular 2009 very rare so 2 2009 rare equivalent, you have a 2010 rare bat and a 2019 common plus some unknowns.

Unfair to your ghost cat, it is worth 6 to 9 2009 rares or a 1 MA pet ^^ they would need to add 4 to 7 more 2009 rare pets. However there is good demand for a ghost cat, I think you can do better than non list pets/09 rares. My opinion anyway!

[talos]

would this be a fair trade? i wanna make sure before making any decisions XD
link to trade

I got chu

So the very rare ghost cat is worth 1 MA (I am ignoring the pride rats as we don't know their rarity)

The Dark Pointy Leopard-Spot dog is a regular 2009 very rare so 2 2009 rare equivalent, you have a 2010 rare bat and a 2019 common plus some unknowns.

Unfair to your ghost cat, it is worth 6 to 9 2009 rares or a 1 MA pet ^^ they would need to add 4 to 7 more 2009 rare pets. However there is good demand for a ghost cat, I think you can do better than non list pets/09 rares. My opinion anyway!

tysm for letting me know this helps me gauge what my ghost cat is worth as well >w<