The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Pantherpaws!! :D]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105339994&userid=1076044&signature=2FN1OYkOwfLNJBMeakXGbA Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105342392&userid=1076044&signature=Yv2agYU2Z8-3SkjY3UGv_Q Could someone lmk if this is fair? Also my first question (at the top of this page!) Never got answered!

[GhostDove]

I wanna make sure this trade is fair before I send it

trades/edittrade.php?partner=980803

(if that link doesn't work I'm offering a 2020 uncommon and a 2020 common for two 2020 uncommons, I don't know values well T-T)

[wolf'srain-toboe]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105341736&userid=45799&signature=y5F_5hAQf19Oaf_gc9mAtw

Need help making this fair

[mcfly,]

I wanna make sure this trade is fair before I send it

trades/edittrade.php?partner=980803

(if that link doesn't work I'm offering a 2020 uncommon and a 2020 common for two 2020 uncommons, I don't know values well T-T)

I would recommend either another 2020 common on your side! OR replace the 2020 common with another 2020 uncommon! (You could offer a 2020 rare instead of either pets currently on your side if you have them, but personally I'd stick to the other suggestions)

[BlueEyedKite]

I wanna make sure this trade is fair before I send it

trades/edittrade.php?partner=980803

(if that link doesn't work I'm offering a 2020 uncommon and a 2020 common for two 2020 uncommons, I don't know values well T-T)

Yes this link doesn't work. According to the trade guides you should match rarity for rarity in the same year. So for 2 2020 uncommons you should offer 2 2020 uncommons. Or 2 2020 commons will equal the value of 1 2020 uncommon.

This doesn't factor in demand though so I would need to know the 2020 common pet if somehow it trades for more due to user demand c: doubtful but you never know.

[Trphlthdl]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105342287&userid=595519&signature=st1VHg0N2REyEzxjbfVHGg

Could someone please let me know if this trade for a store gryphon is fair, factoring in demand? Thank you!

[ph0enicks]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105333066&userid=933740&signature=3Ivr14-2VCSontIPzH1swg

could i have some help with this? thanks :>

[BlueEyedKite]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105342287&userid=595519&signature=st1VHg0N2REyEzxjbfVHGg

Could someone please let me know if this trade for a store gryphon is fair, factoring in demand? Thank you!

2017 store gryphons (except the pps) trade for 1 to 2 2009 rares. Their side is the equivalent of 6 2009 rares (converting 2 2010 rares to 1 2009 rare) then you have the 2013 and 2022 pet add.

This is overpay for the store pet but it depends if you like the pets or not. I know some folks who only trade store pet for store pet since store pets can never be re-released and will only increase in value. Something to think about c:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105333066&userid=933740&signature=3Ivr14-2VCSontIPzH1swg

could i have some help with this? thanks :>

The ur flower pot is worth 1 Non or 10 to 12 MAs

The red malk dragon is worth .25 to .5 Non due to true date demand, 2012 Alien Dog is 1 MA, Strawberry dog 1 MA, 2014 robo cat .5 MA, 2 2015 scaly pps .5 MA x 2 at 1 MA, PPS manticore can go for 1 to 1.5 MA, 2015 adult manticore is .5 MA,
finally the store cheetah goes for .5 MA. This is a little over 1 Non if you have the red malk at .5 Non and then add either 5 to 6ish MAs (.5 Non)

I would say this is fair if you want the UR. Keep in mind store pets can never be re-released so their value will only increase since they can't be recirculated. I like to add that disclaimer when giving store pet involved trade advice ^^

[stream.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105330440&userid=794685&signature=JfqkF2e9cfBfygiNeRgleQ
I think it's fine, just want to make sure !

[mymelody<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105337365&userid=1064257&signature=yJJUiD0JA8hxtD-hHl107Q
I have no idea on items. Tysm to any help!♡

none of those items have any sort of value besides the 1 UC of their year, so this is very unfair to you![/quote]
Thank you so much!♡
Edit: this one go answer by Lex. Tysm!♡