The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Caraxes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105569152&userid=209623&signature=hiEzaEneyZYOT_nj78ZrMA

Is this fair? GWJ for my Malk Dragon pps?

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105569152&userid=209623&signature=hiEzaEneyZYOT_nj78ZrMA

Is this fair? GWJ for my Malk Dragon pps?

If I remember correctly, the pps dragon goes for 1.5 Nons, whereas the GWJ goes for 1 non so they would need to add 0.5 nons

[powpowx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105566566&userid=943796&signature=lp_b3nMnq23NY4PKXvzhAg Hi, I’ve gotten one response that says it’s fair and one that says it’s overpay, do you think I could get a tiebreaker? Demand wise, do you think it would be wise for me to accept this? I have the UR Lion. Thank you for any help <3

[Lex.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105566566&userid=943796&signature=lp_b3nMnq23NY4PKXvzhAg Hi, I’ve gotten one response that says it’s fair and one that says it’s overpay, do you think I could get a tiebreaker? Demand wise, do you think it would be wise for me to accept this? I have the UR Lion. Thank you for any help <3

I'd say this is just fair. Not overpay, just fair. But I also think you could get a better array of pets. Unless you really want the moonswirl and other pets, I'd decline and search for a different offer.

[Numathehusky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105569399&userid=965804&signature=xZfhfGHAQhxC8Jm-SX3Uog
Fair?

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105569399&userid=965804&signature=xZfhfGHAQhxC8Jm-SX3Uog
Fair?

The bwolf on their side is listed for 0.5 MA = 3-4 '09 R (Strawberry Poison Dart Bwolf)

Your side adds up to 2.5 '09 rares (2020 store = 1 '10 R), so you'd be slightly underpaying

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105566566&userid=943796&signature=lp_b3nMnq23NY4PKXvzhAg Hi, I’ve gotten one response that says it’s fair and one that says it’s overpay, do you think I could get a tiebreaker? Demand wise, do you think it would be wise for me to accept this? I have the UR Lion. Thank you for any help <3

I'd say this is just fair. Not overpay, just fair. But I also think you could get a better array of pets. Unless you really want the moonswirl and other pets, I'd decline and search for a different offer.

I agree with this^^^^

UR Lion has such huge demand value, you can get much higher demand pets <3

[Guzma]

Received this trade and wanted to know if it would be considered is this fair?

I do wanna take a jab at guessing things though to see if I'm understanding the guides I've been tryna read so correct me on this if any of it is wrong:

PPS Cheetahs can go up for 1 MA. If I'm counting the warrior as it's original release at 2009, then my side would total up to like 3 '09 rares (with the 2 '10 R = 1 '09 R) I think? So it would end up being underpay on my side right?

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

Received this trade and wanted to know if it would be considered is this fair?

I do wanna take a jab at guessing things though to see if I'm understanding the guides I've been tryna read so correct me on this if any of it is wrong:

PPS Cheetahs can go up for 1 MA. If I'm counting the warrior as it's original release at 2009, then my side would total up to like 3 '09 rares (with the 2 '10 R = 1 '09 R) I think? So it would end up being underpay on my side right?

Very good working out!! You're very almost right!!

The warrior cats (actual warrior cats, not all sitting cats) have very high demand. The rare warrior cats go for 0.5 MA (3-4 09 rares) and the very rares go for 1 MA.

So you are right in saying the 2 2010 rares and 1 2009 rares add up to the 2 09 rares, however your warrior is worth more so it would make your side worth 5-6 2009 rares.
1 MA is worth 6-9 2009 rares. But I'd say warriors can get the higher side of 0.5 ma with the demand which would put it at a solid 6 so it would be on the lower side of fair, but fair nonetheless!!<3<3<3<3

[GhostPants]

I havent been on the site since 2020 and now getting back into it idk anything, how does this trade look?
Trade
GhostPants