The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105527965&userid=896768&signature=-8hLjbRYxGp6UPPff9H7tg

Is this fair? I don't think so but I'm not educated on trading lol, thank you in advance!! :3

Hi! I'm on the other side of this so get a second opinion!

But I worked it out as the ghost garb and tree item are both popular items from 2014, worth a 2014 uncommon each.
A 2014 common is worth a 2016 rare.

2 2017 rare Rats = 1 2016 rare so I'm overpaying with those two items. The rest is overpay for demand of the rare tag and them being pets <3

[keayi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105528514&userid=767773&signature=JqJbv99aB7qKAoq0v3pV7w
Is this fair? A few are Dec. 18th pets so I’m not sure of their true value!
Edit: the Royal Swirl is a basic 2008 and the Embers dog is a basic 2009 but I’m still stuck! :)

Hoshike BDay dog = reg. '09 VR = 2 '09 R
'10 R = .5 '09 R
Royal swirl = reg. '08 VR = 2-4 '09 R
Total = 4.5-6.5 '09 R

For:
Layered fire malk = reg. '09 VR = 2 '09 R
'09 R
Mime PPS = .5-.75 MA = 3-6 '09 R
Total = 6-9 '09 R

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105527965&userid=896768&signature=-8hLjbRYxGp6UPPff9H7tg

Is this fair? I don't think so but I'm not educated on trading lol, thank you in advance!! :3

Hi! I'm on the other side of this so get a second opinion!

But I worked it out as the ghost garb and tree item are both popular items from 2014, worth a 2014 uncommon each.
A 2014 common is worth a 2016 rare.

2 2017 rare Rats = 1 2016 rare so I'm overpaying with those two items. The rest is overpay for demand of the rare tag and them being pets <3 :)

2 '22 C
1.25 '23 R (c incl)
2 '23 unknown
Tree Trunk = 2013 April = '13 UC/R
Ghost Garb = 2014 Halloween = '14 UC/R
2014 Menorah = '14 UC
3 Face Scarves = 2018 Xmas = 3 '18 C/UC
Green Firework Contacts = 2019 NY = '19 C/UC

For:
3 2017 rares = 1.5 '16 R = 0.75 '15 R = 0.375 '14 R = 0.1875 '13 R (if you use 2:1 rule and calc for difference in year)

They're definitley overpaying with the items alone. I'd put the tree trunk and the ghost garb as rare for being older items and more difficult to find, which would have been enough for the '17 rats alone.

[Emoji66]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529201&userid=1078451&signature=sJ2-QmlRWIN4ARRCJtw4bg
Is this fair???

[tenor the rat god]

hey guys :>
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529210&userid=668461&signature=aC_W7ZCVT_ApaQjTLVSFUA
is this a fair trade?

[keayi]

hey guys :>
trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529210&userid=668461&signature=aC_W7ZCVT_ApaQjTLVSFUA
is this a fair trade?

Peppermint ear advent/striped ear snowflake dog = 1 MA = 6-9 '09 R

For:
Spotted tribal cat = reg. '09 VR = 2 '09 R
9 '21 Stores = 1 2010 R/ea = 9 '10 R = 4.5 '09 R
Total = 6.5 '09 R

[PinkAngel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529201&userid=1078451&signature=sJ2-QmlRWIN4ARRCJtw4bg
Is this fair???

(2023un 2023un)(2023un 2023un)(2023un)
(2022un. 2022un)(2023un)
2021un/2023un

(2023c 2023c)(2023c 2023c)(2023c)
(2022c. 2022c)(2023c)
2021c/2023c

(2023vc)

(2021c)

(2021un)

In total we have so far:
2021un/2021un/2021c/2021c/2023un/2023c/2023vc

(2021un 2021un) = 2020un or 2019c
(2021c 2021c) = 2020c
2023un = 2022c
2023c
2023vc

2019c/2020c/2022c/2023c/2023vc


Unknowns can range to a omgsc-rare. I tend to value unknowns as uncommons. Their side does not add up to a 2014common even with all the pets combined. Even if the 2023 unknowns came out as rares, I don’t think all the pets would equal out to be 2014common regardless.

4:1 rule (if unknowns were rare)
2023r = 2021un
(2021un 2021un)(2021un 2021un)
2020un. 2020un
2019un or 2018c (if all 4 unknowns were rare)

[ruffblue]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529393&userid=746976&signature=YUTdaHg8msmWp_1_s6jgYA

Is this trade fair? I'm bad with calculating c$ value rip

Edit: fixed the link! Thank you for letting me know it wasn't working

[rotz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529393

Is this trade fair? I'm bad with calculating c$ value rip

Hi, we can't see your trade! Remember to use the share link at the bottom of said trade!

[AuroraFier]

Which pet that they're offering would be the best trade for the rare they'd like?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529602&userid=1064234&signature=UPQYU0WB47lHar-mw_HkVA

[rotz]

Which pet that they're offering would be the best trade for the rare they'd like?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=105529602&userid=1064234&signature=UPQYU0WB47lHar-mw_HkVA

The '17 rare would be the most fair to both them and you; they'd have to add another '18 rare to compensate the worth disparity if going by the 2:1 'rule'.