The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lucida]

How is this trade?

I'm assuming it's overpay on their side, but I also have had some pretty high offers for the Angel Cheeta, so I'm not sure.

Also curious what I'd need to add to make this trade fair.

[glitter]

Ohkay so just curious... I've been sitting on this trade because it scares me a little bit and I want maybe a couple of opinions. I like the Cheshire cause it's a store pet and has high demand, but... I'm not so sure about the 09 UR Dog AND If I pay 0.5 Nons for the Cheshire am I going to be able to get that amount back? Or should I wait for a different offer?

the cheshire has better demand than a sorbet and its possible to get .5 nons with it. however keep in mind it tends to fall between .25 and .5 nons. also, its a store while the sorbets r rereleases so its value should go up in the future.

the 09 ur dog for a sorb is a completely fair swap.

i think it just depends on how much u want the cheshire. personally i would take the trade.

[justina valentine]

is this fair/how can we make this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=104787530&userid=769336&signature=-C3BdJ2wLvjYgi4e3zNJOg

The sunback is worth 3-3.5 nons. The liontail alone is worth 3 nons, the blue balloon is another .5 nons and the cake dog is another 2 MAs. The cake dog definitely isn't needed, as for the other pets involved, it depends how you and your partner personally value them as to if you removed the blue balloon or not.

Thank you for your input this helps a lot <3

Could i please get a couple more opinions if anyone else can too

[glitter]

is this fair/how can we make this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=104787530&userid=769336&signature=-C3BdJ2wLvjYgi4e3zNJOg

The sunback is worth 3-3.5 nons. The liontail alone is worth 3 nons, the blue balloon is another .5 nons and the cake dog is another 2 MAs. The cake dog definitely isn't needed, as for the other pets involved, it depends how you and your partner personally value them as to if you removed the blue balloon or not.

Thank you for your input this helps a lot <3

Could i please get a couple more opinions if anyone else can too

the sunback actually gets 3.5-4 nons pretty easily. recent trading thread actually shows it getting up to 4.5 nons.
Since your cake dog is true date it can get up to .25 nons. i'm counting 3.75 nons on your side which falls perfectly within the 3.5-4 non range. i think this is a reasonable, fair trade if not slightly under if viewing the sunback at 4.5 ^^

[glitter]

How is this trade?

I'm assuming it's overpay on their side, but I also have had some pretty high offers for the Angel Cheeta, so I'm not sure.

Also curious what I'd need to add to make this trade fair.

for the second trade, the grinner is 2 MA while your side is 1 MA. you would have to add another MA to make it fair!

[NULL VOID]

Ohkay so just curious... I've been sitting on this trade because it scares me a little bit and I want maybe a couple of opinions. I like the Cheshire cause it's a store pet and has high demand, but... I'm not so sure about the 09 UR Dog AND If I pay 0.5 Nons for the Cheshire am I going to be able to get that amount back? Or should I wait for a different offer?

the cheshire has better demand than a sorbet and its possible to get .5 nons with it. however keep in mind it tends to fall between .25 and .5 nons. also, its a store while the sorbets r rereleases so its value should go up in the future.

the 09 ur dog for a sorb is a completely fair swap.

i think it just depends on how much u want the cheshire. personally i would take the trade.

Thanks for the response! I am a bit worried I won't be able to trade away the 09 UR Dog though. Even if it is a fair swap. It's never really interested me so I haven't paid that much attention to it.

[~Loki~]

Ohkay so just curious... I've been sitting on this trade because it scares me a little bit and I want maybe a couple of opinions. I like the Cheshire cause it's a store pet and has high demand, but... I'm not so sure about the 09 UR Dog AND If I pay 0.5 Nons for the Cheshire am I going to be able to get that amount back? Or should I wait for a different offer?

the cheshire has better demand than a sorbet and its possible to get .5 nons with it. however keep in mind it tends to fall between .25 and .5 nons. also, its a store while the sorbets r rereleases so its value should go up in the future.

the 09 ur dog for a sorb is a completely fair swap.

i think it just depends on how much u want the cheshire. personally i would take the trade.

Thanks for the response! I am a bit worried I won't be able to trade away the 09 UR Dog though. Even if it is a fair swap. It's never really interested me so I haven't paid that much attention to it.

If I were you, I’d probably cancel as the UR dog can be hard to trade. If you’re interested in the Cheshire you could always edit it to be a swap for one of the sorbets.

[Aleigh]

Would the voodoo PPS cat be a fair swap for one of the 2014 store adult dragon cats? I thought the voodoo was a regular VR but I could be wrong

[NULL VOID]

Ohkay so just curious... I've been sitting on this trade because it scares me a little bit and I want maybe a couple of opinions. I like the Cheshire cause it's a store pet and has high demand, but... I'm not so sure about the 09 UR Dog AND If I pay 0.5 Nons for the Cheshire am I going to be able to get that amount back? Or should I wait for a different offer?

the cheshire has better demand than a sorbet and its possible to get .5 nons with it. however keep in mind it tends to fall between .25 and .5 nons. also, its a store while the sorbets r rereleases so its value should go up in the future.

the 09 ur dog for a sorb is a completely fair swap.

i think it just depends on how much u want the cheshire. personally i would take the trade.

Thanks for the response! I am a bit worried I won't be able to trade away the 09 UR Dog though. Even if it is a fair swap. It's never really interested me so I haven't paid that much attention to it.

Thank you for responding Loki! I think I will edit it. That's the part of the trade that has me concerned. I appreciate the advice you both gave!

[hachirou]

hello! i've just returned to cs and I'm a little bit lost on the store pet values. i'd like to get an opinion on this trade! thank you in advance!