The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Deerdancer]

Is this ok? Involves four pets for four items.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103375820&userid=203847&signature=gEDc2VcYQPqmoVTbtY4Rxw

[appaloosa816]

how is this looking?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103378769&userid=483044&signature=c7u9m4cmoauut7uKbEh1kg

Haha oops I quoted someone else’s post, anywho is anyone able to give me some advice on my list?

[musicgurl333]

Would this trade be fair, and would you personally accept it? They're valuing the green dragon at 4 '09 rares. I have 128 lions on my side.

lion counts:
'11 uncommons = 10
'12 uncommons = 22
'13 uncommons = 21
'13 commons = 4
'14 uncommons = 39
'14 commons = 32

Lions of note (I've found these can go for slightly more, with the snow lion having the highest demand of the group): '12 snow lion, 2 uncommon PPS cubs, 4 '13 purple winged Advent lions

Thank you in advance for any help!

-musicgurl333

[CadillacPhunque]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103385078&userid=174933&signature=pcJXq67Q4iqF4TL2DKuO3g

[Bernese]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103385078&userid=174933&signature=pcJXq67Q4iqF4TL2DKuO3g

yes this is fair!
using the 2:1 rule their pets are the equivalent of 4, 2010 uncommons. Technically, most people do 2:1 (ex, 2, 2010 uncommons for 1, 2010 rare) but they are offering 4:1 so they are offering overpay.

[realmagenta]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103385180&userid=756200&signature=5MnzhWGRWLkTf_Uo7NlgQw

Is this a fair trade?

[~Loki~]

Would you take this? I’m really looking for the store pet but the gf Holly I don’t care about. I already have 2

[Bakura]

Is this a fair swap?
I've had multiple people cancel the same trade and I'm not sure if I'm paying enough.

The trade is fair! Both pets are valued at 1 MA or 6-9 09 rares

Is there a demand difference (I dont really follow demand), because even with the deer in a trade folder and the BW on their wishlist, it's still being rejected XD

[appaloosa816]

how is this looking?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103378769&userid=483044&signature=c7u9m4cmoauut7uKbEh1kg

I really don’t know what I’m doing j just want a fair trade for my pet, so please help anyone:) I appreciate It in advance!

[Animall]

Is there a demand difference (I dont really follow demand), because even with the deer in a trade folder and the BW on their wishlist, it's still being rejected XD

The deer is not worth as much as your bwolf by rarity. A 2015 store pet is worth 2-3 09 rares, and a 2012 store pet is worth 1 ma. The deer is worth 1ma by demand and your bwolf is worth 1ma on rarity. People are just preferring their deer over the bwolf.