The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Screemnigcheesepuff]

Really need help with this one

they're over by a lot, especially the vr

Please be careful with advice, if you use the 2:1 rule ro convert lower values into unc and then use the c$ guide the total value is about
Thier side; c$89
Your side c$130
So actually your side is over by quite a bit

More details below

Thier side

2011= 20
2016 store= 55 but has some demand so may go for higher
2017=8
2019=4
2022x2= 2

Your side
2014 unc= 5
2016 unc=3
2017 unc=2
2018 uncs x 6= 9
2019 x 5= 5
2020 unc x 15= 11.25
2021 unc x 108= 81
2021 r x 2= 4
2022 unc x 20= 10

[Columbina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103361488&userid=938992&signature=S4ahTjjk0GYrbTsn-GpUHQ

[appaloosa816]

Is this fair?

Still looking for some advice:) It’s my list dog for a lower list pet and store pet

[holodog]

Really need help with this one

they're over by a lot, especially the vr

Please be careful with advice, if you use the 2:1 rule ro convert lower values into unc and then use the c$ guide the total value is about
Thier side; c$89
Your side c$130
So actually your side is over by quite a bit

More details below

Thier side

2011= 20
2016 store= 55 but has some demand so may go for higher
2017=8
2019=4
2022x2= 2

Your side
2014 unc= 5
2016 unc=3
2017 unc=2
2018 uncs x 6= 9
2019 x 5= 5
2020 unc x 15= 11.25
2021 unc x 108= 81
2021 r x 2= 4
2022 unc x 20= 10

C$ values and conversions are highly subjective and this is NOT the way to judge the fairness of a trade, especially considering the C$ values on that guide thread are very outdated and do not consider demand. If that's the way you do it, then you're free to, but objectively it is not a good way to give advice. I would personally consider this unfair to their side, especially considering they have a store pet that is part of a set that is well-liked. To the original poster, it is up to you how you value bulk in these amounts but I would highly recommend checking that this person knows what they're offering.

[BlueRaz11]

Would this be fair? I know nothing about OMG rares.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103378577&userid=265745&signature=1lbWGfrXfHyom6UDiN_wsw

[Bakura]

Is this a fair swap?
I've had multiple people cancel the same trade and I'm not sure if I'm paying enough.

[PinkPound]

Is this a fair swap?
I've had multiple people cancel the same trade and I'm not sure if I'm paying enough.

The trade is fair! Both pets are valued at 1 MA or 6-9 09 rares

[+Vesper]

Would this be fair? I know nothing about OMG rares.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103378577&userid=265745&signature=1lbWGfrXfHyom6UDiN_wsw

Fair, both are 1 non demand wise.

Note: Zebra's have bad demand - but in my subjective opinion that Zebra is worth more because of it's adopted date (since it was adopted not on dec 18th)
****just my opinion tho, trade is good otherwise!

edit. checked the demand; zebra is worth 0.75-1 and dog is about 1
So technically they're underpaying by demand.

[Zaliaetus]

Hi, what do you think about this trade?

Unsure of demand for both, but of course based on just rarity and date it would not be fair. Thank you!

[Dark-Mercenary]

Really need help with this one

Snip

Please be careful with advice, if you use the 2:1 rule ro convert lower values into unc and then use the c$ guide the total value is about
Thier side; c$89
Your side c$130
So actually your side is over by quite a bit

More details below

Thier side

2011= 20
2016 store= 55 but has some demand so may go for higher
2017=8
2019=4
2022x2= 2

Your side
2014 unc= 5
2016 unc=3
2017 unc=2
2018 uncs x 6= 9
2019 x 5= 5
2020 unc x 15= 11.25
2021 unc x 108= 81
2021 r x 2= 4
2022 unc x 20= 10

C$ values and conversions are highly subjective and this is NOT the way to judge the fairness of a trade, especially considering the C$ values on that guide thread are very outdated and do not consider demand. If that's the way you do it, then you're free to, but objectively it is not a good way to give advice. I would personally consider this unfair to their side, especially considering they have a store pet that is part of a set that is well-liked. To the original poster, it is up to you how you value bulk in these amounts but I would highly recommend checking that this person knows what they're offering.

Agree with holodog, it's a 2016 store cheetah. I forgot how much is worth (I think either 0.5/1 MA) but do not use the C$ values. The cheetah is c$ is worth 250-300c$ I think. So the top side with the cheetah is worth way more than the bottom. Please don,t accept, I would explain to the person on the other side of this trade. Be nice and treat them fairly. If they do know then it's fine.