The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Silver Pandorica]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193354&userid=859775&signature=RqkZZ4kAQqCgsxTB9eYzhw
how is this? I feel like its looking kinda over on my side (the dogs) but do people really trade this much for lions?

You would be overpaying by an extreme amount. Even just one of the dogs on your side would be overpay. I don't think that particular lion has any special demand and is just worth the three-month rule.

[zenisiti]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193354&userid=859775&signature=RqkZZ4kAQqCgsxTB9eYzhw
how is this? I feel like its looking kinda over on my side (the dogs) but do people really trade this much for lions?

Hi! While lions are in high demand, this is overpay on your side, one 2011 rare(while it may be a lion) is not worth 3 09 rare dogs + 2 2010 rares

[Ghōst]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103192475&userid=792268&signature=SLPepJ0roJ6WFnnEqDIR_w
The trade is already done and I'm happy with it but I was wondering if it was fair c:

[kiwifyee<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193354&userid=859775&signature=RqkZZ4kAQqCgsxTB9eYzhw
how is this? I feel like its looking kinda over on my side (the dogs) but do people really trade this much for lions?

You would be overpaying by an extreme amount. Even just one of the dogs on your side would be overpay. I don't think that particular lion has any special demand and is just worth the three-month rule.

ahhh, okay thats kinda what I was thinking thanks so much guys! <3

[kiwifyee<3]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193354&userid=859775&signature=RqkZZ4kAQqCgsxTB9eYzhw
how is this? I feel like its looking kinda over on my side (the dogs) but do people really trade this much for lions?

Hi! While lions are in high demand, this is overpay on your side, one 2011 rare(while it may be a lion) is not worth 3 09 rare dogs + 2 2010 rares

ahh alright thank you so much<33

[ShinyUmbreon13]

another bid I need help with
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103188956&userid=917321&signature=riBdzl2tjOn_Z8Cfyk2HvQ

[marmoris]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193051&userid=529351&signature=JkW-17VSQ_l0QnOcmkhjfA

is the demand better for the liontail or the seals? what would be best for trading

[beeves]

could i have some help with this one please? <3

[soup guardian]

hi! i need another opinion on this warrior cat offer.
im a recently returning user so my knowledge on rarity is lacking.
i do like the store pet and 2010 dog, but i was told i could be asking for more.

[I’m Bored]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103193051&userid=529351&signature=JkW-17VSQ_l0QnOcmkhjfA

is the demand better for the liontail or the seals? what would be best for trading

In terms of value, the pps seal pups are worth .75 non’s each, i don’t believe they’ve gone up, so 4 would be 3 non’s. The Lion tail would be on average 3 nons depending on who wants it but I’ve seen it go both sides of 3 nons. Generally speaking I’d say yes this fair value wise, demand for both is subjective, but I’d wait for more value advice to get a better idea.