The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Animall]

I understand the value of this trade, but would you accept? Seriously considering it and I don't want to regret it. I paid 2.5-3 nons for my pastel but the Dragoncat demand continuously keeps growing.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176534&userid=39760&signature=jeOjBfcC_EtrxWNsu5Fx6Q

Nvm please no advice because I accepted it and want to enjoy it xD

[Vampie!]

A little bit of a large trade, but I need someone's help
The trade in question
They're asking for these pets, plus my rares+ folder, plus all of my uncommons and below. Would this be fair, and even without asking about fairness, is this a wise trade? What's the Nick Uni worth, would trading it for something I want be easy/hard?

[WispyWoods]

I agree with you! It seems like a fair trade to me :D
I would accept it, but I also love the UR holly

Thank you for the response, it definitely helps! Can I get one more opinion? The UR holly dog isn't one of my personal dreamies, but is it better to trade it up for dreamies than nons and sorbs are?

I've noticed it's been really hard for people to trade away their ur holly dogs post-holiday season, but maybe that's just my experience. I personally think the quantity would serve you better than the holly dog.

Thank you for the help and insight to trading! I really appreciate the different perspectives:)

[BlueEyedKite]

Could someone help me with this please? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176518&userid=1040946&signature=HfzTn3bxgUvfaY_ke0-rQg

Your grinner is worth 1.25 to 2 MA and the most valuable pet there, the palomino tess horse, is worth 1.5 to 2 MA so with the tess horse alone they are equal in value

That said I don't care much for tess horses so I would decline since I would trade a ginner for 2 MA dogs. Up to your preferences really

[ShinyUmbreon13]

Need to know how much this bid is worth

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169997&userid=917321&signature=nCsZHSS9UU3Pde2WKaMwYA

[Anaraktu]

Can anyone help me with these trades please?

td nontag for my green liontail

moonswirl for my ur dragon

ur rainbow dog for my green liontail

trade with staff pets

ur kirin and green toxic for my green liontail

multiple pets for my green liontail

items and pets in this trade

malk and avocado and c$ for my green liontail

aussie and coontail for green liontail

Also this bulk trade for the green liontain

Hey! This will be a long one, so strap in! I WILL NOT BE TAKING DEMAND IN TO ACCOUNT UNLESS I TALK ABOUT IT FOR A SPECIFIC TRADE. DEMAND CAN AND WILL ALTER THE WORTH OF SOME PETS.

FIRST TRADE: Non swirl is, as the name suggests, one non. HOWEVER, THE NONSWIRL THEY ARE TRADING YOU IS A TRUE DATE. This may affect the worth, I have linked a trade below that is the MOST RECENT successful trade of someone valuing the td nonswirl at more than 1 non.

Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4150112&p=137258530&hilit=nonswirl#p137258530

That being said, the green liontail consistantly goes for 3 nons, so even if someone valued the TD Nonswirl at the price in the link above, it still wouldn't be worth your lion tail.

Forum/search.php?keywords=%22green+liontail%22&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

NOT FAIR!

SECOND TRADE: RR Moonswirl fetches 2 - 2.5 nons. The worth for the new UR PPS Dragon is FLUCTUATING, and hasn't settled in terms of worth. It has gone anywhere from 1.5 nons all the way up to 2.5 nons, so this honestly is up to you and how you value the pets. I will note, though, since the UR PPS Dragon is so new, it obviously has higher demand right now. The value of it may drop OR RISE, so take this with a grain of salt.

UP TO YOU!

Forum/search.php?keywords=moonswirl&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=ur+dragon&t=4150112&sf=msgonly


THIRD TRADE: As I said before, the green liontail fetches 3 nons. The new UR Rainbow dog fetches 2.5 - 3 nons, fetching the higher end more frequently/recently. Like I said with the new UR PPS Dragon, the value MAY CHANGE. It is up to you, BUT SOMETHING TO NOTE: Store pet worths don't often change, as they can NEVER be rereleased like regular rares+ can. Usually people value their older store pets more because of this, so take this as you will.

FAIR/UP TO YOU

FOURTH TRADE: Your '22 rare is actually a rerelease of an 09 staff pet, which would make their side no where near worth your side. I COULD BE WRONG, as I'm not sure what that growing pet is. PLEASE CONSULT SOMEONE ELSE TO SEE WHAT THAT PET IS TO GET THE FULL PICTURE.

archive/2009/November/

not fair UNLESS that growing dec 18 pet is from 2009 as well!

FIFTH TRADE: RR toxics always go for .5 nons. UR Kirin has been going for 2 - 2.5 nons, and as said above the green liontail is 3 nons. This is a fair trade DEPENDING ON HOW YOU VALUE THE PETS.

Forum/search.php?keywords=longma&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

FAIR/UP TO YOU

SIXTH TRADE: UR Holly goes for 1.5 nons consistantly, while the RR BA is always a non. The TD null PPS has been seen going for .5 nons most recently, and the RR hyena seems to go for 1 MA.


Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=UR+Holly+-uWIbnX8ONiZcg8LciQMN7A+-qgGoSBQ9JKX1N0RAWMFzfw+-rIWPxVdM1cKwFNvLc4oaGw+-KQFvYpcPR2DkSA+BA&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1
Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=UR+Holly+-uWIbnX8ONiZcg8LciQMN7A+-qgGoSBQ9JKX1N0RAWMFzfw+-rIWPxVdM1cKwFNvLc4oaGw+-KQFvYpcPR2DkSA&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1
Forum/search.php?keywords=null&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=hyena+-lilac&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1

FAIR/THEIR SIDE SLIGHTLY OVER (not taking demand in to account!)

SEVENTH TRADE: I'm not too sure on the worth of items, so I won't comment on them. From the pets alone, though, their side is SEVERELY UNDER.

NOT FIAR(just taking pets in to account)

EIGTH TRADE: I belive one non is 1.5k - 2k C$, BUT I MIGHT BE WRONG, I'm not good with C$ ;_; It does have very shakey demand, though, so keep that in mind. The UR Malk goes for 1.5 nons, while the avocado goes for .75 - 1 non. the two warriors go for .5 ma EACH.

Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=UR+Malk+-908Q+-GPycBjogQ+-FK2x72rP1u7TZb34tNlGjQ+-oM716wjxBVK5RraMx3by2A+-vqSva+-Nt6gA6hiafZbUrn340n7qQ+-S59Faxsv9wetipHfW6cD7A+-FtW6tn9H+-345c1g0mAycM0mPeLFrm1A+-JtYnF+-wAfdEzzKIIeA8tPocUrSyA+-9Nq1n4syPNS9nWnPocFVvA+-gEXdW+-rarUoCDD6C9KWYsW84t9DA+-St7vA+-3k5v4kDpPVCYzcQah1PgFA+-yPb1ffApD3nHfmkZrrqQGg+-P2eT+-dff5DiFhScSTDJ8kjXCexA+-e3WRv5I5kJw+-9gQVF8SQCmrePiFecnngPQ&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1
Forum/search.php?keywords=avocado&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

UP TO YOUR DISCRETION

NINTH TRADE: RR coontail goes for 2 nons, while the RR UR Aussie goes for 1 non.

Forum/search.php?keywords=coontail&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=UR+Aussie+-IOVOQ&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1

FAIR!

TENTH TRADE: Just looking at it I know IT ISN'T ANYWHERE NEAR FAIR. Feel free to get a second opinion, as I don't feel like it's worth the time breaking down their side's worth since it's blatantly unfair!


Hope this helped! YOU ARE ENTITLED TO A SECOND OPINION, PLEASE GET ONE IF YOU WANT ONE <3!!

That was a lot but thank you very much! Would anyone have a second opinion maybe?? Especially with demand into account?

[xXxAetherxXx]

Could someone help me with this please? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176518&userid=1040946&signature=HfzTn3bxgUvfaY_ke0-rQg

Your grinner is worth 1.25 to 2 MA and the most valuable pet there, the palomino tess horse, is worth 1.5 to 2 MA so with the tess horse alone they are equal in value

That said I don't care much for tess horses so I would decline since I would trade a ginner for 2 MA dogs. Up to your preferences really

I probably will cancel since I’d rather trade it for something better. Thank you for the help!

[~Loki~]

I know it’s technically fair, would you personally accept?

I wouldn't. The store pets don't come back to the game ever, but the pets on their side can. In my opinion, store lists have better demand.

Thank you! Can I have one more opinion please?

[Silver Pandorica]

Is this fair? I just got the balloon and am hesitant to trade it away, but if it's a good offer I might consider, especially since I need the buns for my collection ^^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176693&userid=774258&signature=2x0tWfAOO4UenN65Gyvdew

[Animall]

Is this fair? I just got the balloon and am hesitant to trade it away, but if it's a good offer I might consider, especially since I need the buns for my collection ^^
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176693&userid=774258&signature=2x0tWfAOO4UenN65Gyvdew

The sunjewel bun is worth 0.25-0.5 nons, but tends to trade on the lower side of around 3 MA. I personally think you could find the bun for a better value elsewhere.