The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[I am Pokémon]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176307&userid=1025137&signature=nKnqOpAzVOiPW2EoCrxeXQ



Is this a fair trade I accepted the trade but now idk if it was that fair (the 2018 pet was a store pet)

[soarin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176307&userid=1025137&signature=nKnqOpAzVOiPW2EoCrxeXQ



Is this a fair trade I accepted the trade but now idk if it was that fair (the 2018 pet was a store pet)

oh, oh no, oh dear. this isn't fair to you at all. that's a zodiac dog. it's worth 0.5 MA (3-4 '09 rares) and im quite afraid the c$ doesn't make it fair either. 2018 store pets are woth a late '09 rare and 2022 store pets are worth an early '11 rare. if i were you i'd ask them if you could get a tradeback.

i encourage you to ask this thread before accepting a trade for a december 18th pet, however.

[Vampie!]

A little bit of a large trade, but I need someone's help
The trade in question
They're asking for these pets, plus my rares+ folder, plus all of my uncommons and below. Would this be fair, and even without asking about fairness, is this a wise trade? What's the Nick Uni worth, would trading it for something I want be easy/hard?

[rainbowbanda]

Hi I was wondering if this would be a fair trade? Going by horrors worth it says .5 non is worth 1000 C$ so I was just wondering if it would be over pay for 1200 C$

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176035&userid=868291&signature=sHUEPjePw97u_Ds21NmObw

[Animall]

Hi I was wondering if this would be a fair trade? Going by horrors worth it says .5 non is worth 1000 C$ so I was just wondering if it would be over pay for 1200 C$

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176035&userid=868291&signature=sHUEPjePw97u_Ds21NmObw

It's not uncommon for people to ask for more c$ than it is worth because c$ generally has low demand and people prefer to keep their pets instead of selling them. I would say that this is fair but it's entirely up to you on how you utilize and value your c$. I personally refuse to overpay for pets when I buy with c$.

[Lemon Coyote]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169415&userid=841851&signature=0SabOz8Fk0rEIteCsFv90g
bulk trade warning!
I am looking for huge bulk but I'd like to know if I could still get more? Thanks

[WispyWoods]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

I agree with you! It seems like a fair trade to me
I would accept it, but I also love the UR holly

Thank you for the response, it definitely helps! Can I get one more opinion? The UR holly dog isn't one of my personal dreamies, but is it better to trade it up for dreamies than nons and sorbs are?

[Animall]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally :) multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

I agree with you! It seems like a fair trade to me :D
I would accept it, but I also love the UR holly

Thank you for the response, it definitely helps! Can I get one more opinion? The UR holly dog isn't one of my personal dreamies, but is it better to trade it up for dreamies than nons and sorbs are?

I've noticed it's been really hard for people to trade away their ur holly dogs post-holiday season, but maybe that's just my experience. I personally think the quantity would serve you better than the holly dog.

[Animall]

I understand the value of this trade, but would you accept? Seriously considering it and I don't want to regret it.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176534&userid=39760&signature=jeOjBfcC_EtrxWNsu5Fx6Q

Edit: sorry I'm on mobile I didn't mean to double post!

[xXxAetherxXx]

Could someone help me with this please? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176518&userid=1040946&signature=HfzTn3bxgUvfaY_ke0-rQg