The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102969948&userid=961352&signature=MFNokKH1SrAPxhORp8-ccg

is this fair for my Brown Corgi?

Hi! a heads up that I won't be using evidence links for this advice, so take it with a grain of salt as I'm going off memory and recent values I've seen for the pets! PLEASE GET A SECOND OPINION IF YOU'D LIKE ONE<33!

The pets on their side are mostly fodder except the stores. It can be argued that both stores are .5 MA each, as they have weird demand. However, some people only value them at 1-2 09 rares, so just be aware of this.

Your store corgi, however, does have a consistant value of 1 MA: Forum/search.php?keywords=corgi&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

1 MA is 7-8 09 rares. Going by the 2:1 rule for the fodder pets (2 '10 rares = 1 09 rare) their side is worth 5 09 rares from the fodder '10 pets alone.

I'd say their side is a tad over, going off this. However some may see it as equal value because of the high demand for the store corgis and the lower demand of the pets on their side (such as the hooved fodder pets)

This is really up to you, personally I would trade my corgi for more in demand fodder rares so it's easier for me to trade them :)

PLEASE GET A SECOND OPINION IF YOU'D LIKE ONE!! Hope this helped :)

[clefairy]

how's this trade i recieved?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=102846902&userid=1053595&signature=6T02Pjgy11NEs1Cp3EhRtQ

[rainbowbanda]

Hi I was wondering if this would be a fair trade? Going by horrors worth it says .5 non is worth 1000 C$ so I was just wondering if it would be over pay for 1200 C$

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103176035&userid=868291&signature=sHUEPjePw97u_Ds21NmObw

[NIER AUTOMATA]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103173843&userid=960212&signature=220bTWQTVimvVbNMVwq1zg

Is this fair?

Would like to know as well

[I forgot]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102969948&userid=961352&signature=MFNokKH1SrAPxhORp8-ccg

is this fair for my Brown Corgi?

Hi! a heads up that I won't be using evidence links for this advice, so take it with a grain of salt as I'm going off memory and recent values I've seen for the pets! PLEASE GET A SECOND OPINION IF YOU'D LIKE ONE<33!

The pets on their side are mostly fodder except the stores. It can be argued that both stores are .5 MA each, as they have weird demand. However, some people only value them at 1-2 09 rares, so just be aware of this.

Your store corgi, however, does have a consistant value of 1 MA: Forum/search.php?keywords=corgi&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

1 MA is 7-8 09 rares. Going by the 2:1 rule for the fodder pets (2 '10 rares = 1 09 rare) their side is worth 5 09 rares from the fodder '10 pets alone.

I'd say their side is a tad over, going off this. However some may see it as equal value because of the high demand for the store corgis and the lower demand of the pets on their side (such as the hooved fodder pets)

This is really up to you, personally I would trade my corgi for more in demand fodder rares so it's easier for me to trade them :)

PLEASE GET A SECOND OPINION IF YOU'D LIKE ONE!! Hope this helped :)[/quote]

Thank you so much!! I've posted around 10 times and could never get a response 😵‍💫 Thank you!

[WispyWoods]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally :) multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

[Lemon Coyote]

Hello! I recently got a trade that has made me very indecisive oops. I've been trying to educate myself more on rarities so here is my question and trade. Also if I am wrong about anything with rarity then please do correct me!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103169733&userid=572597&signature=33Uv0Jwwpcupqny6QCWEZA

I think the UR holly dog goes for 1.5 nons, and I know the noncoon is 1 non and the sorb is 0.5 non. So it seems to be a straight even trade. But my question is whether or not other people would accept this offer personally multiple opinions welcome and thank you!

I agree with you! It seems like a fair trade to me
I would accept it, but I also love the UR holly

[Vampie!]

A little bit of a large trade, but I need someone's help
The trade in question
They're asking for these pets, plus my rares+ folder, plus all of my uncommons and below. Would this be fair, and even without asking about fairness, is this a wise trade? What's the Nick Uni worth, would trading it for something I want be easy/hard?

[~Loki~]

I know it’s technically fair, would you personally accept?

[Lemon Coyote]

I know it’s technically fair, would you personally accept?

I wouldn't. The store pets don't come back to the game ever, but the pets on their side can. In my opinion, store lists have better demand.