The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[cloven]

Hi- is this fair? I don’t know the item worths that well :(((

[miyoni]

is this fair ?

[DarkNights]

is this fair? thanks :)

also this one?

[CoffeeEX]

is this fair ?

Cucumber goes for a solid non: Forum/search.php?keywords=cucumber&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

The cucumber does have a lower demand though, and may be hard to trade off. Your side value is below VV

Alien dog 1 MA, Pink fairy goat 1 MA, Plains zebra .75n-1n (Most recent was valued at .75, but past valued at 1N. It just depends on its demand.)

This is honestly up to you, and how you value your pets and what you think about the past trade data. I hope this helps, please get a second opinion if you want one! Have a good night<3

Forum/search.php?keywords=alien+dog&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=fairy+goat&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=plains+zebra&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

[CoffeeEX]

is this fair? thanks :)

also this one?

FIRST TRADEl Hi :) The sunback has been going for 3.5 nons in the two most recent trades, however it has gotten as much as 4-4.5 nons in the trades just below: Forum/search.php?keywords=sunback&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

Just looking at this trade I can tell you it is NOT FAIR TO YOU. The UR holly has lower demand and only goes for 1.5 N: Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=UR+Holly+-uWIbnX8ONiZcg8LciQMN7A+-qgGoSBQ9JKX1N0RAWMFzfw+-rIWPxVdM1cKwFNvLc4oaGw+-KQFvYpcPR2DkSA&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1

The other pets on their side DO NOT add up to make up for the rest of what the sunback is worth. I won't do links for this one (as I'm sure other people can agree, just by looking it isn't fair to you..) HOWEVER I will provide evidence if you need it or someone else needs it :P

SECOND TRADE: The bee has been going for 3 nons consistantly: Forum/search.php?keywords=bee&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

This is slightly under, however the bee does have nice demand at the moment. I would ask them if they can make up for the .5 non deficit IF YOU LIKE THE BEE AND WANT TO TRADE FOR IT.

You are entitled to a second opinion if you want one! I hope this helped, have an amazing day<3!

[Caraxes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=103170807&userid=209623&signature=SXeyZ4JuLcfWjB80RBBegw

Is this a fair suggestion?

[~Loki~]

Thoughts?

And this one as well

Even if you can help with just one of the trades it’s super appreciated!

Cinnabun goes for a solid 2N: Forum/search.php?keywords=cinnabun&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

2N = 20 - 24 MA. Please add this up yourself I am very tired x)

First trade: TD Red-Fronted holly 1 MA most recently, TD Purple heart husky 1.5 MA (Most recent info is on RR, i linked the TD info and the rest below), TD orange swirl 1.5 MA (Again, this is the most recent value for TD. RR goes for 1 MA solid, some people value TD different), TD Boar PPS 1 MA, 2x RR Bone PPS 2 MA, 2x RR orange swirl 2 MA (not gonna link again), RR Pink heart dog has no recent info, but since it is the same tier as the bone PPS we can guess it's 1 MA(feel free to get another opinion), Fairy goat 1 MA, RR Kiss PPS 1 MA, RR Dark grey tag husky 1 MA, RR Mustard husky 1 MA, RR Firework PPS 1 LA(Most recent), RR Ice blue swirl 1 MA

Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=red+fronted+holly+-rIWPxVdM1cKwFNvLc4oaGw&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1
MOST RECENT TD HEART HUSKY VALUE Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=4150112&p=139245416&hilit=purple+heart+husky#p139245416
WHOLE VALUE PAGE Forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=purple+heart+husky&t=4150112&sf=msgonly&ch=-1
Forum/search.php?keywords=orange+swirl+pps&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=boar&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=bone+pps&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=fairy+goat&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=kiss+pps&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=tag+husky&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=mustard+husky&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=firework&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=ice+blue+swirl&t=4150112&sf=msgonly


UR Dragon PPS has been FLUCTUATING. Has gone from 1.5N up to 3N. Your call on how you value it: Forum/search.php?keywords=PPS+dragon&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

Second trade: Only gonna value the non-fodder pets. Orange tree 1.5-2n, bandersnatch 1 MA, Jabberwocky 1 MA

Forum/search.php?keywords=orange+tree&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=bandersnatch&t=4150112&sf=msgonly
Forum/search.php?keywords=jabberwocky&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

Hope this helped

Thank you SO MUCH <3<3

[CoffeeEX]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103170807&userid=209623&signature=SXeyZ4JuLcfWjB80RBBegw

Is this a fair suggestion?

Howdy!

The worth of the PPS Dragon is SHAKEY AND UNDETERMINED. Such is the life of the new Special Release x)

Most recent trades have valued it anywhere between 1.5 nons up to 3 nons: Forum/search.php?keywords=UR+Dragon&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

That being said, their side worths are as follows:

Sorbs are each worth .5 nons as I'm sure many people know, so I will not be giving a link for this (I can provide links if you or someone else needs the evidence, though!) Cheshire cat has been recently seen going for .25 nons, and the RR nonswirl is, as the name suggests, worth 1 non :)

Their side adds up to 2.25 nons, which is in the sweet spot for the worth of the UR PPS Dragon. I would say this is fair DEPENDING ON HOW YOU VALUE THE UR PPS DRAGON.

PLEASE take in to account that while the worth of the UR PPS Dragon may shift, their pets' worths are pretty set in stone (minus the cheshire cat, sometimes the demand for it is higher so it goes for higher, yadda yadda..)

I hope this helped, have a lovely day :) Please be aware you are allowed to get a second opinion<33!

[Caraxes]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=103170807&userid=209623&signature=SXeyZ4JuLcfWjB80RBBegw

Is this a fair suggestion?

Howdy!

The worth of the PPS Dragon is SHAKEY AND UNDETERMINED. Such is the life of the new Special Release x)

Most recent trades have valued it anywhere between 1.5 nons up to 3 nons: Forum/search.php?keywords=UR+Dragon&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

That being said, their side worths are as follows:

Sorbs are each worth .5 nons as I'm sure many people know, so I will not be giving a link for this (I can provide links if you or someone else needs the evidence, though!) Cheshire cat has been recently seen going for .25 nons, and the RR nonswirl is, as the name suggests, worth 1 non

Their side adds up to 2.25 nons, which is in the sweet spot for the worth of the UR PPS Dragon. I would say this is fair DEPENDING ON HOW YOU VALUE THE UR PPS DRAGON.

PLEASE take in to account that while the worth of the UR PPS Dragon may shift, their pets' worths are pretty set in stone (minus the cheshire cat, sometimes the demand for it is higher so it goes for higher, yadda yadda..)

I hope this helped, have a lovely day Please be aware you are allowed to get a second opinion<33!

Thank you!

[Sashtato]

I’m pretty sure these guys are the same value wise but I just wanted some opinions, thanks!!

xxx

Howdy! they actually aren't the same in terms of value, as your PPS is the Kiss PPS, an ex-list pet that still holds it's list value. It is seen going for 1 MA when it's a RR: Forum/search.php?keywords=kiss+pps&t=4150112&sf=msgonly

The BWolf is just a VR on the other hand with no extra value added to it, and would be worth the 3 month rule. This trade is unfair to you.

I could be wrong if you follow other lists, however I follow successful trades Feel free to get a second opinion<3

Thank you so much!! I didn’t realize that, so I’ll see about another opinion to get a better idea, I appreciate it a ton!