The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[[noted]]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102948926&userid=316453&signature=vEFm38iNwpaPqeIoAiLIVA

I'm really bad with pets dating back this far. Theirs are re-releases from Dec. 2008 and Apr. 2010. Help is appreciated!

target dog = 2 MA
their PPS dog is worth 1 MA or half your dog, but the other bun doesn't cover the rest of the gap. They would need to add another 0.5 MA value, or 3-4 2009 rares worth

Thank you!!

[CHINARIZING]

Heya, can I get some thoughts on the C$ worths of these trades? Currently I value both trades as just shy of 200C$ or equal or slightly over it.

Trade 1
Trade 2

[Valak]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102948916&userid=909012&signature=UsTUo5yLqG5JcEXUl_tAZA

is this fair for my ur dog

[Fierce Wings]

Just got this offer for my BA. I'd love to get an opinion or two. I don't want to keep the people offering waiting for too long. I'm EXTREMELY tempted to accept it. Any help is greatly appreciated. <3

XXX

Can I please get some help? 🙏

[Galaxy Figs]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102892307&userid=106411&signature=puKXzDz7ac3600dFUxcVeA

is this fair ? or at minimum, y'all know if any of the items on my side are worth anything ?

[Skull.Vincent]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102948916&userid=909012&signature=UsTUo5yLqG5JcEXUl_tAZA

is this fair for my ur dog

While the value of the UR dog is highly variable right now and does not have a set value yet, it's being traded at 2-3 nons right now.

For their side:
UR Pineapple @ 1 non
UR Grapes @ 0.5 non
Relative to 2k C$ = 1 non, ~2500 C$ = 1.25 non
Growing Horses: 2009 VR, 2009 rare, 2009 R or VR (None have any special value/demand that I'm aware of)
Camel: 2014 RR Rare
Lion: 2010 RR rare
+ 10 '09 rares + 4 '10 rares + 2 other rare RR + 2022 store pets (worth an '11 rare each I believe)
Grand Total: 2.75 non + (this could vary depending on how you value VR relative to rare/demand & value of RRs) 2ish MAs.
I would say this is fair in value alone, however, I would take into account the possibility that it can be very difficult to trade off food URs such as the pineapple and grapes.

[Nira.]

Hi, can somebody take a look at these groups for me and tell me around what they are worth?
It's been a hot minute since I actively traded and I'm awfully out of the loop regarding current
demands, trends, and what has changed over the year :'D

Group 1 (11 pets)

Group 2 (21 pets)

Group 3 (14 pets)

Group 4 (10 pets)

Any help is much appreciated and thank you in advance ♡

[NEOtwewy]

how's this offer for a UR strawberry?

i've never gotten a UR before and i'm just. bad at trading with high rarity so please help :c

edit: this one too? ik the store pet is worth 2 MAs but i'm not sure about rares math + not sure about exact warrior cat rarity lol

and this

[Pancake2112]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102951009&userid=1030395&signature=DFGSBpbWcayhGHFUMFy0kA

HELP, this is the biggest trade ive ever done

[edgeworth.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102950563&userid=869235&signature=Uw3CPSPLOMzeZ_yGm7WAQg

not good with trades with more than like 3 pets loll