The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[freya.mikaelson]

a bit confused about the item worth, any help is appreciated :)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102528603&userid=412178&signature=aTMhOvfsSltfpfq02nDSjA

[teariffic]

hi ! i declined the trade but just curious, is this fair or unfair? boop

[נוריאל]

How was this trade? I already accepted, but I'm curious ^^;
Happy holidays everyone!

angel advent = 0.25nons

0.25 non = 3-4MA

1 MA = 6 '09 rares
2021 store pet = 1 '10 rare
using the 2:1 rule:
all '21 store pets = 6 '09 rares + the '10 rare would equal 7 '09 rares
if a '09 rare is worth around 40c$, the c$ provided would be worth 4.6 '09 rares.

2 MAs + 1 '09 vr (2 '09 rares) + 7 '09 rare value + c$ = ~3.75MAs

this would be an under for the angel advent for about ~0.25MA worth, but not too bad :] might wanna get another opinion though!

Thank you very much! ^^;

[lullaby]

Is this fair, I'm don't have much knowledge on VR trades
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102536727&userid=993767&signature=hD_yMSnn0zj8ptrhDhCQMw

Any help?

a '19 store pet is worth a '10 rare, so the rare on their side would be fair alone. they're overpaying :]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=102520684&userid=913801&signature=OuZyF9hym6Jsd1nZiYbnYQ

I've never had such a high value trade so I'm not sure

RBM is worth 1non, grevy's zebra is also worth 1non
though the zebra tends to go for less than a non, the RBM seems to consistenly go for one non. you're overpaying with the extra pets on your side

[Guest]

How was this trade? I already accepted, but I'm curious ^^;
Happy holidays everyone!

angel advent = 0.25nons

0.25 non = 3-4MA

1 MA = 6 '09 rares
2021 store pet = 1 '10 rare
using the 2:1 rule:
all '21 store pets = 6 '09 rares + the '10 rare would equal 7 '09 rares
if a '09 rare is worth around 40c$, the c$ provided would be worth 4.6 '09 rares.

2 MAs + 1 '09 vr (2 '09 rares) + 7 '09 rare value + c$ = ~3.75MAs

this would be an under for the angel advent for about ~0.25MA worth, but not too bad :] might wanna get another opinion though!

Just wanted to note that 1 MA = 6-9 '09 rares, so 6 '09 rares is actually the lower end of the spectrum ^^

[lullaby]

I know year/rarity wise that this trade is unfair to the other person, I just wanted to double check if the 2022 Halloween banner dragon currently has any sort of demand that may make this fair or unfair in the opposite direction? (I know during the event it had insane demand, but I haven’t seen much about it recently)

trade

typically banner pets usually always have an insane amount of demand for them whenever their rarity is unknown, but said demand almost always immediately plummets the second rarities are released. i personally haven't seen the banner pets going for much more than they're worth now imo, so i don't think any sort of demand would make up for the trade. i hope this helps!

hi ! i declined the trade but just curious, is this fair or unfair? boop

oh geez, going by the 2:1 rule, the rare they're offering is worth only 2 '22 uncommons. one of your '18 uncommons would have been waayyy overtrade enough!

How was this trade? I already accepted, but I'm curious ^^;
Happy holidays everyone!

angel advent = 0.25nons

0.25 non = 3-4MA

1 MA = 6 '09 rares
2021 store pet = 1 '10 rare
using the 2:1 rule:
all '21 store pets = 6 '09 rares + the '10 rare would equal 7 '09 rares
if a '09 rare is worth around 40c$, the c$ provided would be worth 4.6 '09 rares.

2 MAs + 1 '09 vr (2 '09 rares) + 7 '09 rare value + c$ = ~3.75MAs

this would be an under for the angel advent for about ~0.25MA worth, but not too bad :] might wanna get another opinion though!

Just wanted to note that 1 MA = 6-9 '09 rares, so 6 '09 rares is actually the lower end of the spectrum ^^

you're right! i just usually go for the minimum worth of pets so it's easier to decide if a trade is fair or not, rather than having to find a median, providing values for every inbetween value, or going for the maximum value that doesn't really appear too often in trades :]

[teariffic]

hi ! i declined the trade but just curious, is this fair or unfair? boop

oh geez, going by the 2:1 rule, the rare they're offering is worth only 2 '22 uncommons. one of your '18 uncommons would have been waayyy overtrade enough!

thank you so much !! i thought so as well [i've been reading up on trading rules since coming back from a hiatus] but i wanted a second opinion !!

[Corey Taylor]

Would this be fair to me? (LIST TRADE)

[vxlentine]

I don't deal with pets of this value very often, so I'm not very educated in trades like this.
Keeping demand and such in mind, would this trade be fair?
(Click)
Thank you so much for any help!

[kiergane]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=102535707&userid=393605&signature=Q20t18yGsphyE-jxDxKe2g
Hi!
I know the pet I'm trading for is in high demand so I wanted to make sure. Is this fair?
(I've only returned fairly recently so I'm still new to rarities)