The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Merp.com]

is this fair? I don't care much for items anyways and I want to collect the full set of the store pet they have.

[Vaal Hazak]

is this fair? I don't care much for items anyways and I want to collect the full set of the store pet they have.

Unfair to you
these items sets were limited for one month each, and were sold for 15 c$
a 2019 store pet is worth a mid 10 rare while a 2020 store pet is worth a late 2010 rare
you would need to add like an late 2010 - early 2011 uncommon so even one of the birthstone sets is overpay

[qhost]

Could I have some advice on these two trades? Store pets always confuse me haha.

One
Two

Thanks in advance!

[Merp.com]

how about now? I added 30 chicken dollars

[Vaal Hazak]

Could I have some advice on these two trades? Store pets always confuse me haha.

One
Two

Thanks in advance!

not sure about the first trade

but the second one is clearly unfair to you
the 2019 store deer is worth 2 mid 10 rares maximum, considering it was a set bonus
the first five pets would already cover that

[whitekitten28]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101610394&userid=609355&signature=VNE_1WHPp-tQbrdVxn6Xbg for a Raven Dog

Malk Elemental Fire Cat -1MA
Point-eared Border Collie - 1.5-2MA
Green birthday sitting car -1MA
Floppy pink September dog - 2.5MA
White string Tess horse - 1MA
Red string Tess horse - 1MA
Pink heart event dog - 1.5-2MA
WWA - 0.25non 3-4MA
Butterfly wolf coon - 1MA
Malk Elemental Water Cat - 1MA
Timer wolf Advent - 2MA
Watermelon dog - 1MA
Floppy pink September dog - 2.5MA
Winged Blood Dog - 2MA
Palomino Tess horse - 2MA
2009 Jade PPS - 2 09 rares
Chocolate Easter dog - 0.5MA
Panda PPS - 2 09 rares
Black and tan corgi - 2MA
Blue Merle corgi - 2MA
Peppermint ear dog - 1MA
White Appaloosa - 2 09 rares
Coralline Gupps - 2 09 rares
Donner horse - 2 09 rares
Teal paisley Tess Dragon - 2 09 rares
Purple Sortic - 0.5MA
White/Green Warrior Dog - 0.75MA
Pointed Zombie Dog - 2 09 rares
Pointed zombie Dog - 2 09 rares
Firework PPS - 1MA
Dark brown valentine 2nd gen - 2 09 rares
Long tailed scribble dog - 09 rare
Olive green field/ meadow dog - 2 09 rares
Pointy field/grass dog - 2 09 rares
White scarf/snowflake dog - 1MA
Floppy green pastel dog - 4 09 rares
Ying & Yang dog - 1MA

Roughly 37-38 MA = Roughly 3.5nons

Followed horrors list & what is this pet worth thread.

Items =
Raven perch order X10 - 10MA
Hammer - 2 MA
Nails x2 - 0.50nons (8MA)
Gold cloth - 0.25non (4MA)
Red cloth - 0.25non (4MA)
Pocky - 0.5MA
Dog tag plushy x2 - 2MA
Rat plushy - 0.5 MA
Chicken horse blanket - 0.50 nons (8MA)
Werewolf feet - 2MA
Werewolf mane x2 - 4MA
Back spikes - 2MA
Werewolf teeth - 2MA
Halloween candy sucker and ghost - 1MA
Yellow chicken suit - 2MA
Angel wings - 0.25nons (4MA)
Silly glasses 1 x2 - 4MA
Silly glasses 2 x2 - 4MA
Butterfly wolf plushy - 0.5MA
Laptop - 1MA

Roughly 53MA = 5nons worth in items

Followed gay’s item guide.

8.5nons?

Could I get a second opinion on this! I’m not the greatest with rarities

[~Ash Wolf~]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101626036&userid=266261&signature=nBUfXpS6sFwUFHobkl8Oxw
is this fair, I feel like they are slightly overpaying

[Shwimp]

Would anyone be able to tell me how many nons this is?

[jay]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101621242&userid=1001960&signature=DPnqYfpkg-twc6ZYfRsIsQ

thoughts?

[c0otiez]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101617428&userid=10160&signature=J1g8LIAtcum1MGkI1QFtRQ

Thoughts/opinions on this please? Any help would be greatly appreciated, thank you!