The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[AnnieDarlingxo]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101506967&userid=321906&signature=r7UvILxqTFhbV26h6ueyJw

Is this fair? The items are from the 2014 Egypt Event.

[SilverDreams7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101506967&userid=321906&signature=r7UvILxqTFhbV26h6ueyJw

Is this fair? The items are from the 2014 Egypt Event.

Unfair to you. Items usually go for an uncommon of the same year. Using the 2:1 rule, their side is about 1 and 1/2 2019 uncommons, not even close to the value of one of your items, but I'd assume they just didn't know.

[Ariconnie48]

Is this fair?

[SilverDreams7]

Is this fair?

unfair to you. 2021 store pets are a '10 rare each, so your side is over by the '09 b-wolf. take the b-wolf away and it's fair.

[pristine]

would this pet be fair for a zodiac dog? what would I need to add if not? I have no idea about demand anymore and don't know a lot about this pet.

[marmoris]

xx

would this be a good trade? i've been hesitant to trade off the august PPS as i'm not really quite sure on what they're going for these days. i am looking for the rose dog, but as i said i'd like to make sure it's a fair deal.

quick edit, also, i really could use advice on this offer as well. i already have the smores, so they'd be solely fodder. are the smores somewhere similar to the value of the cinnabun?

[the pale elf]

would this pet be fair for a zodiac dog? what would I need to add if not? I have no idea about demand anymore and don't know a lot about this pet.

zodiac dogs typically go for .5 MAs. im not super sure about the demand of the horse but personally i wouldnt accept this.

xx

would this be a good trade? i've been hesitant to trade off the august PPS as i'm not really quite sure on what they're going for these days. i am looking for the rose dog, but as i said i'd like to make sure it's a fair deal. :)

quick edit, also, i really could use advice on this offer as well. i already have the smores, so they'd be solely fodder. are the smores somewhere similar to the value of the cinnabun?

the august pps seems to be worth 0.25 to 0.5 nons, but it has insane demand! a td red rose goes for about 0.5 nons so i would say with demand that this is fair, but feel free to get another opinion!

as for the second trade, the ur s'mores pretty steadily goes for 1.5 to 2 nons. the ur cinnabun is worth 2 nons, so i think it just depends on how much your trading partner values the s'mores!
bmd buns seem to be worth roughly 0.25 - 0.5 nons on horror's list, so 7 of them would equate to about 1.75 nons if you value them on the lower end of the scale, meaning that if you value them higher, you would be overpaying by quite a margin. i would get a second opinion on this one though, because im not 100% sure about the buns worth!

[Charbee]

Is this fair? With my ultimate goal of getting the UR Bee
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101510633&userid=206448&signature=PMhvrzUT5U7ZEs09vNPC2w

[yellingrock]

any help? I have no clue if this is fair or not! ty!! :D

[감정을]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101512601&userid=780015&signature=ZGHOSo8kWKv4GcGuNnXoDQ not sure on item worth