The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SilverDreams7]

This corgi:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101478050&userid=346122&signature=rME2iVwoGfJ-FqUGl06-Rw

For my whole common group (1140 pets from 2012-2021)
accounts/viewgroup.php?groupid=2478040&userid=346122

I know one dont usually put value on common pets since its "hard" to tradeup that amount but is it somehow fair and worth the bother?

anyone pls

Corgis are 1 MA, or 6-9 '09 rares. using 2:1 with rares to uncommons, would be 288 2012 commons. 4:1 it would be 576, but that's soo many pets. from your 2013-2011 pets in the group, it's about 166 2012s, which (using 2:1) would leave you with 122 2012 commons to fill. I don't think the rest of your pets make up for that, so your partner would technically be overpaying with the corgi, but at the same time that's so many pets to trade for just 1, and I personally wouldn't.

[mrgbmommy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101455786&userid=421490&signature=RvJzQnNuYI7LckUx3U3kVA

Hello! Is this fair? Thank you so much

I'm on the other side of this, could we get an opinion of fairness please?

[reflections.]

h???? i don't know what this little guy is worth, any help? thank you :]

[longlive]

Hi! Is this fair? I have no idea the worth of warrior cats. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101481688&userid=98669&signature=eFrwGvw-KfMd1HrVwjPkmw

[Zaria]

Is this fair to the person who sent the trade to me?
C$100 for 39 pets

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101467502&userid=64236&signature=v3VBjXBHRAK0kJoxgk_0vg

What do you think is a more reasonable amount for them to offer?

[SilverDreams7]

Hi! Is this fair? I have no idea the worth of warrior cats. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101481688&userid=98669&signature=eFrwGvw-KfMd1HrVwjPkmw

The Elemental malk cats and VR warrior cats are both 1 MA each. Regular rare warriors go for 3-4 '09 rares each. They were asking for about 1.5 MA of overpay, although their malk cat is a TD (but so are your rare warriors), which some people value really highly.

[hayzel]

how is this for my 2015 store deer set?

they sent a similar trade yesterday but i declined as it was a bit under. they added some more pets and sent it back, so we'd both like another opinion before proceeding any further! just a warning, there's a bit of bulk <3 thank you in advance!

[SilverDreams7]

Is this fair to the person who sent the trade to me?
C$100 for 39 pets

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101467502&userid=64236&signature=v3VBjXBHRAK0kJoxgk_0vg

What do you think is a more reasonable amount for them to offer?

Actually, they're underpaying. Your side would be worth around 125 C$

[Zaria]

Oh I'm so confused, someone else said they were over paying and I already told them I thought it was unfair to them because of what the other person said

[Rbpuppy]

Hi! Is this fair? I have no idea the worth of warrior cats. Thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101481688&userid=98669&signature=eFrwGvw-KfMd1HrVwjPkmw

Definitely unfair to you especially considering the warrior cats demand