The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Tazmir]

Could someone assist?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101448182&userid=129112&signature=MrEPTvufCDC1YxjiDNuqAw

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101478786&userid=880031&signature=mDXyfkYDEBRkveEOoPhvsw

Is this fair? Thanks in advance

You’re about 5 C$ short if you value the 2010 Rares at their max which is 40 C$ and the 09 VR at its max of 55 C$. Still a solid offer though c:

[Arctic⚡️Storm]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101475297&userid=119435&signature=4Wx43btYN-RnsMXjCOyw-g

Is this bid fair? Not sure how to measure pet worth by the non/MA system etc. Thanks in advance

[Arcanine Luver]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101475297&userid=119435&signature=4Wx43btYN-RnsMXjCOyw-g

Is this bid fair? Not sure how to measure pet worth by the non/MA system etc. Thanks in advance

I would consider this unfair!
Toxic - 0.5n
Red rose - 0.25-0.5n
Line tribal - 0.25n
Pink sept - 2MA

The pink september makes your side overpay, but if it were me i personally wouldnt take this trade regardless unless you really like the UR foal! The dogs on your side trade really well but the foal has extremely low demand and sometimes trades for less than it is worth.

[EditPink]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101479335&userid=902320&signature=MDRJpkyW0AaCmMbGXoX9-g

[hayzel]

how is this for my 2015 store deer set?

they sent a similar trade yesterday but i declined as it was a bit under. they added some more pets and sent it back, so we'd both like another opinion before proceeding any further! just a warning, there's a bit of bulk <3 thank you in advance!

[GhostFaceッ]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101472430&userid=739856&signature=S8qVIhvNJEsN-T4q52PaqQ
are the TD rose dog and pps rose dog worth a non-tag? and is this fair demand wise as well? need advice, thank you!

[Rbpuppy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101472430&userid=739856&signature=S8qVIhvNJEsN-T4q52PaqQ
are the TD rose dog and pps rose dog worth a non-tag? and is this fair demand wise as well? need advice, thank you!

The Red Rose PPS goes for .25-.5 Nons (I’d consider it .5 since it’s a TD) and the Red Rose goes for .25 Nons. Again since they’re both TD I’d value them a little higher but I still believe it’s unfair to the Non tag by roughly .25 Nons.

[S0fte]

unsure about this one.

[showtis]

This corgi:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101478050&userid=346122&signature=rME2iVwoGfJ-FqUGl06-Rw

For my whole common group (1140 pets from 2012-2021)
accounts/viewgroup.php?groupid=2478040&userid=346122

I know one dont usually put value on common pets since its "hard" to tradeup that amount but is it somehow fair and worth the bother?

anyone pls