The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[mrgbmommy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101455786&userid=421490&signature=RvJzQnNuYI7LckUx3U3kVA

Hello! Is this fair? Thank you so much

I'm on the other side of this, could we get an opinion or two?

[Bernese]

this?

i know it's fair but i do NOT want to trade off list... should I keep them or no? is it easy to trade back onto the list?

[not zinnia]

Fair or nah?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101472512&userid=758444&signature=9gQBRzXJjzLFdKrgl2EJ-g

I think the C$ offer should be 7 or 8. People sell their 2021 uncommons for between 1-3 C$ each, so that would be 6 at minimum right there, plus the 3 2021 very commons which should at least be worth 1-2 C$ total

[not zinnia]

this?

i know it's fair but i do NOT want to trade off list... should I keep them or no? is it easy to trade back onto the list?

In my experience people really don't want to trade their lists for bulk. Most others I've come across want list pets of equivalent or higher value in exchange for their lists. Of course some people do want bulk but I feel they're harder to come across

[not zinnia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101474657&userid=1004512&signature=YPJqXUg37lqSyJ9db5HEWg

need help asap!

Some people value the eggs very highly, but others couldn't care less about items! It depends on how much you care for items, and if you're in it for the long run

[Oragami_Cyclone]

how is this for my 2015 store deer set?

they sent a similar trade yesterday but i declined as it was a bit under. they added some more pets and sent it back, so we'd both like another opinion before proceeding any further! just a warning, there's a bit of bulk <3 thank you in advance!

Bumping for trade partner!

[not zinnia]

A little uncertain about this trade - I've seen a lot of contrasting sources about the Sockdog's value (some going as high as Sorbet tier from Horror's List, although demand is low). Would this be fair for a TD Sockdog and October? Thank you in advance :).

The hollyfox has fairly high demand, and I don't believe I've seen any particular demand for the sock dog. However! It is a TD, which some people value wildly high.

Do you personally care for TD VR/OMGSRs? I think that's the main question here. If you don't care, then yeah go for accepting the trade! If you do care, then it might be worth thinking a little harder about it. If you want to trade your sock dog for another TD, you might not find someone willing to part with their TD hollyfox (or equivalents) in exchange, so that's something to think about too

[WonderlandWitch]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101464513&userid=244040&signature=cqsWBn3Bdk0QWKWrjemAVA
hello! fair?

[reflections.]

h???? i don't know what this little guy is worth, any help? thank you :]

[Flightstar]

Hello! I haven't traded Store Pets in a while, could someone let me know what they think of this one? trades/viewtrade.php?id=101470165&userid=150818&signature=EKpYlvQ227LhKsRMpOEjYA

Thanks!