The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[PinkAngel]

would this trade be far?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101340930&userid=121954&signature=htAkzH6HeHgiUD9Q1PF6Gg

(edit: monster item on my side is from Halloween 2010)

I'm not to well versed in Items worth, but if the monkey plush is for the Lil monster they're under by a bit since that monkey is from this year CS bday

I agree that the trader is a bit under.

Items are usually valued at uncommons. Trade 1 is not too far off from being a fairish offer if both value the monster as an uncommon. But realistically, I believe the Lil Halloween Monster can go for a 2010 rare or higher. (a mid-late 2010 rare to be more exact)

oThe 2012-06-04 cat from trade 1 will cover the 2012-05-08 cat in trade 2.

oThe 2012-11-05c cat and the 2013-03-30un rat will = a 2012 uncommon. (or a 2011common)
2012 common cat + 2012common rat (converted value)= 2012uncommon which would also equal a 2011common


The unknown 2022-06-01 rarity in trade 1 will cover the 2022-06-01 and 2022-06-01 birds (or if the unknown rarity is valued as a common, then the monkey plush would also cover it)


The Halloween Lil Monster was released in Halloween 2010.
The Monkey Plush is from CS Bday 2022.

Edit: Edited math error

[Ebony Stardust]

Just want to be sure that this is fair?

[PinkAngel]

Just want to be sure that this is fair?

Yes, that is a fair offer. The Eye Contact was released on Halloween 2015.
Items are usually valued at as uncommons, a 2015 uncommon = 4-5C$

Refer to here for the list

[outera]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101370164&userid=942786&signature=MHJDRs31iaSyJj2t4d-2TQ
is this fair to me?? i have no knowledge of any rarities anymore. :p

[PartySugar]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101384391&userid=400382&signature=7coo45j550fO9JF5aNqX_g

Is this fair? I’m not great when the trade starts getting semi bulky ^^’

[SilverDreams7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101384391&userid=400382&signature=7coo45j550fO9JF5aNqX_g

Is this fair? I’m not great when the trade starts getting semi bulky ^^’

Unfair to you. The rares on your side are store pets (you can tell by the little C$ tag under the chicken smoothie signature). The 2020 one goes for a 2010 rare, and the 2022 (technically it's from 2021) one goes for a late 2010 rare. Their side (using 2:1 instead of 4:1, which is sometimes used for uncommons to rares) adds up to at most a 2011 rare (using 4:1 it's only a 2012 rare). Not to mention the rest of the pets on your side.

[rickets]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101389245&userid=813215&signature=1vNmwMtPa3W2EybF8b1GDA 😵‍💫

[SilverDreams7]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101389245&userid=813215&signature=1vNmwMtPa3W2EybF8b1GDA 😵‍💫

Unfair to you. Your store deer trades for 1 MA (6-9 '09 rares), but even if it was a regular 2015 store pet, it would be unfair. 2015 stores go for 2-3 '09 rares. Their 2018 store goes for one '09 rare. The rest of their side doesn't even add up to another '09 rare.

[maxyjax]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101389118&userid=880174&signature=cj8C9nqgcHA0u_iPkur2sg

Is this fair?? Please help I would love these snakes for my hoard but don’t want to outrageously overpay!

[Thegoofyfox]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101389118&userid=880174&signature=cj8C9nqgcHA0u_iPkur2sg

Is this fair?? Please help I would love these snakes for my hoard but don’t want to outrageously overpay!

I'd say since 2022 store pets are worth a 2010 rare, that the 2021 store pets are worth 2010 or more, so just 1 of those store pets are over