The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Funkyfandom]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101261230&userid=1004512&signature=0_JXSEcqkwXj_mA_FA3YMw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101319972&userid=1004512&signature=F82a4D1dbRAXbGzBr1bcBQ

fair? i dont use items


trades/viewtrade.php?id=101334324&userid=1004512&signature=Re3f4Yz1MlIVGWr5OfODbQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101382584&userid=1004512&signature=4bGO3BxvPH4e_HCpx67B_g

and these?

[NightmareSystem]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101374909&userid=376053&signature=tucxzgiXzN4ekzMzPOMRFA

I am trying to figure out if this balanced out, for educational purposes

————————
I believe the top overpaid by a small bit, being that the baby duck was unneeded. But Lions have demand, so that overpay covers the demand for the lions imo.

Bottom Trade:
2022 common x 2 = 2022 uncommon or a 2021 common

2022 uncommon is a 2021 common

2021comm + 2021comm = 2021uncomm

——-
My reasoning example if you have two uncommons from the same year they usually equal a rare if the 2:1 is followed, so I assume it would be the same for the other rarities.
2022r 2022r | 2022un 2022un | 2022c 2022c
2021r ~~~~~~~~ 2021un ~~~~~~~~~ 2021c

——
Edit: In C$

Top
2021un = 0.50C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.625C$
——
Bottom
2022un = 0.25C$
2022c = 0.125C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.50C$

Phew, I do admit that this is extremely difficult to follow 😅

What I am understanding, using 2022 year as an example, if I trade 2 commons for 1 uncommon it would be as fair as if I traded 2 uncommons for 1 rare?

Separate question, using the years 2022 and 2013 as an example. Would the same apply if I traded 2 2013 commons for 1 2022 uncommon or would the value bump the 2022 up to a rare because of the year??

[Wanheda]

Is this fair? Sorry for the formatting, I'm on mobile-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101375335&userid=39854&signature=3qV9Yv63XCvTSSCIU735eg

Would still appreciate an answer on this, I don't want to keep the other person waiting indefinitely when they've been patient already!

An additional question- is this one fair?

I'm always hesitant to trade older store pets tbh and I don't know if I need to be!

[PinkAngel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101374909&userid=376053&signature=tucxzgiXzN4ekzMzPOMRFA

I am trying to figure out if this balanced out, for educational purposes

————————
I believe the top overpaid by a small bit, being that the baby duck was unneeded. But Lions have demand, so that overpay covers the demand for the lions imo.

Bottom Trade:
2022 common x 2 = 2022 uncommon or a 2021 common

2022 uncommon is a 2021 common

2021comm + 2021comm = 2021uncomm

——-
My reasoning example if you have two uncommons from the same year they usually equal a rare if the 2:1 is followed, so I assume it would be the same for the other rarities.
2022r 2022r | 2022un 2022un | 2022c 2022c
2021r ~~~~~~~~ 2021un ~~~~~~~~~ 2021c

——
Edit: In C$

Top
2021un = 0.50C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.625C$
——
Bottom
2022un = 0.25C$
2022c = 0.125C$
2022c = 0.125C$
T= 0.50C$

Phew, I do admit that this is extremely difficult to follow 😅

What I am understanding, using 2022 year as an example, if I trade 2 commons for 1 uncommon it would be as fair as if I traded 2 uncommons for 1 rare?

Separate question, using the years 2022 and 2013 as an example. Would the same apply if I traded 2 2013 commons for 1 2022 uncommon or would the value bump the 2022 up to a rare because of the year??

1. Yes, using the 2022 year as an example, if you traded 2 commons they would equal 1 uncommon. If you traded 2 uncommons they would equal 1 rare. (Very Rares and OMGSR are a bit different. And Storepets do not apply for the 2:1)

2. Using the years 2022 and 2013 as an example. The 2:1 rule does not apply as the 2:1 rule applies to the year of release.
You would need multiple 2022 uncommons or 2022 rares to equal two 2013 commons.

Two 2013 commons would equal one 2013 uncommon
Two 2022 commons would equal one 2022 uncommon


(The 2:1 is a commonly used rule, but you may run into a person who does not see a pet released during January-April = September-December of that year. And depending on the pet, people may see it as worth a bit less even if they are from the same year and rarity. But the 2:1 is the most commonly used)

[Equinox...]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101384045&userid=963181&signature=El0m4p24X11T4ozVBO3hpA

I'm super happy with this trade! Just curious if it was a good deal? (I was totally ok with this)

[The Cure]

does this look fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=101384422&userid=685035&signature=CLhqx_AFKVrFib1MPaARpg

[Skysthelimit]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101384842&userid=422911&signature=EphZizK0IteG_KXbvvgfuw

Pretty sure this is unfair to me... But I wanted to check - item trade!

[Willow.cat]

Is this fair? Sorry for the formatting, I'm on mobile-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101375335&userid=39854&signature=3qV9Yv63XCvTSSCIU735eg

Would still appreciate an answer on this, I don't want to keep the other person waiting indefinitely when they've been patient already!

An additional question- is this one fair?

I'm always hesitant to trade older store pets tbh and I don't know if I need to be!

Not sure about the first one, but id say the second one is fair.
2019 store pets usually go for a late 2010 rare, but keep in mind their value rises overtime, and its VR.
Store pets also have more demand then equines, so personally i wouldnt accept but its down to which side you prefer!

[Loui.]

Hi!

How does this look?

trade

Edit: also how about this one?

I‘m suuuuper tempted, as the Dogtag is a huge dreamie of mine. But I’m not entirely sure on the values compared to each other

Thank you very much in advance

[Wanheda]

Not sure about the first one, but id say the second one is fair.
2019 store pets usually go for a late 2010 rare, but keep in mind their value rises overtime, and its VR.
Store pets also have more demand then equines, so personally i wouldnt accept but its down to which side you prefer!

Thank you for the response, I appreciate it! ❤️