The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000693&userid=686966&signature=mm9D2Ae-bUCr693GaSHkDw

thoughts on this trade? couldn't really find any data on the saber-toothed lioness besides it being sold for 150c$ in may 2022. so is this lioness worth .5 ma? tysm for any help <3

I never heard of the lioness going for 150 C$ nor it going .5 MA but the warrior cat sure does I guess they might value them equally as 2010 rare cat while also overpaying for it.

[goofer goblin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000693&userid=686966&signature=mm9D2Ae-bUCr693GaSHkDw

thoughts on this trade? couldn't really find any data on the saber-toothed lioness besides it being sold for 150c$ in may 2022. so is this lioness worth .5 ma? tysm for any help <3

I never heard of the lioness going for 150 C$ nor it going .5 MA but the warrior cat sure does I guess they might value them equally as 2010 rare cat while also overpaying for it.

thanks for the response ! and i got the 150c$ source from here <3

[Lovehope&kindness]

Can I please get some help..
This is a bid for the full elf costume from 2010 I think.. I have no idea what it’s worth is this a good bid?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100708736&userid=100368&signature=WHXdU0fdmoaBafKG84VUaw

[Wysterinka]

Can I please get some help..
This is a bid for the full elf costume from 2010 I think.. I have no idea what it’s worth is this a good bid?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100708736&userid=100368&signature=WHXdU0fdmoaBafKG84VUaw

not much examples to find for you but looks like it could be around 09 rare per elf hat so depends how many do you auction because I think there are hats and boots of 3 variations or smhtn https://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/search.php?keywords=elf&t=4153787&sf=msgonly

[smiledawg]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101003604&userid=865121&signature=DfrgXvfjINqdPrAgdpOPug help! not sure if its fair since theyre both re releases but mine is quite older

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101003604&userid=865121&signature=DfrgXvfjINqdPrAgdpOPug help! not sure if its fair since theyre both re releases but mine is quite older

for most rereleases, the year they're rereleased in doesn't really matter, just their original dates
though in the case of your pets which are much more valuable than regular very rares, your cake dog is valued at 2 MA, theirs is worth 1 MA or half your dog, so it's unfair to you

[QueenSiren]

I might say no because I like the unicorns but just in case is this fair? Am I overpaying or are they?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101004568&userid=897504&signature=fWq_mj61DKlD33ETqBsvzg

[qhost]

Been out of the trading scene for a bit so I'm not sure about these two trades-

One
Two

Any help would be appreciated, thanks!

[Ravens-Folklore]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101004603&userid=165448&signature=LALMYo0Q01DOKh7znobj8Q

wondering if this is a fair trade. i know the malk fox is older but i've been holding onto the cheetah because of its popularity, and have considered doing a giveaway or possibly an auction on it. not sure what's fair for either of them and if this is good for both of us

[Infailia]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101004603&userid=165448&signature=LALMYo0Q01DOKh7znobj8Q

wondering if this is a fair trade. i know the malk fox is older but i've been holding onto the cheetah because of its popularity, and have considered doing a giveaway or possibly an auction on it. not sure what's fair for either of them and if this is good for both of us

2016 store pets go for 1-2 2009 rares, and considering the popularity of the cheetah you'd probably be able to trade for more. They'd have to add at least another 2010 rare to make this fair to you (if you follow the 2:1 rule). In terms of C$, I have seen 2010 malk foxes going for around 40C$ while I've seen this particular cheetah going for a minimum of 70C$ and sometimes upwards of 100C$. As such, this trade is not fair to you.