The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Llazybonezz]

Is this fair? I feel like this is a lot of overpay on their side?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100997524&userid=631866&signature=uS06Pbx_B3wrqWy3vlhjmQ

yes 2010 rare would be worth more than the pets on your side

That's what I was thinking?? Thank you !

[Wysterinka]

hello,
do you guys think this trade is fair?(:

green tox is between .25 - .5 non depends where you value it but since it's not TD I would say more to the lower side, 2012 somewhat go for 1 MA each and so does the T7 dog and corgi
nonjewel seems to be getting steady 1 non

[Arcanine Luver]

hello,
do you guys think this trade is fair?(:

green tox is between .25 - .5 non depends where you value it but since it's not TD I would say more to the lower side, 2012 somewhat go for 1 MA each and so does the T7 dog and corgi
nonjewel seems to be getting steady 1 non

so then do you think my side is at or over a non?? sorry i just want to be sure before i accept!!

[winx]

hello,
do you guys think this trade is fair?(:

green tox is between .25 - .5 non depends where you value it but since it's not TD I would say more to the lower side, 2012 somewhat go for 1 MA each and so does the T7 dog and corgi
nonjewel seems to be getting steady 1 non

so then do you think my side is at or over a non?? sorry i just want to be sure before i accept!!

It seems your trade partner is valuing the Green Toxic at 0.5 non.
6 MA remains on your side.
0.5 non = 5-7 MA. This would bring your side to 0.25-0.5 + 0.5 non. Thus, your side would either be at or slightly under a full 1 non (depending on how you value your Green Tox). Seconding Wysterinka's above logic as well.

+ add-on - corgis can go up to 1.5+ MA. This would still fall within the 0.5 non range though.

[depressedanonymous,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101001134&userid=652611&signature=riSIHIJzqm8ZdXnMnuqc8g
Any assistance? Tyvm!
-DA

[geobellez]

how’s this trade ? :)

edit: this too please <3

[Wysterinka]

how’s this trade ?

edit: this too please <3

first trade looks fair - 2010 rare per store cat
second trade looks better imo, malk bettas are demanded (could be 3 09 rares worth not sure) and just is the lion cub and the warrior cat 09 (worth .5 MA) + 2010 sitting cat (nice demand) This would be overpay on their side by a lot

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=101001134&userid=652611&signature=riSIHIJzqm8ZdXnMnuqc8g
Any assistance? Tyvm!
-DA

their side: rudolph 1 MA + Android .5n + Gearback Tribal .25n + Blue tox .25-.5n + store unicorn 1 MA + Noncoon 1n + Lineback tribal .25n + 2 rats (not sure which ones are these so get another opinion but I think they are between .25-.5n) = 2.5 non (with tox valued high) + 2 MA + rats that I am unsure of???
your side: CEG 1.5n + white drag .5n + red drag .25n + blue drag pps 1.5n + store pet 1MA = 3.75n + 1 MA (equal swap to their store)

If I were you I would cancel out the store horses first with a swap to make lil smaller trade and get second opinion on the rats as well

[goofer goblin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000693&userid=686966&signature=mm9D2Ae-bUCr693GaSHkDw

thoughts on this trade? couldn't really find any data on the saber-toothed lioness besides it being sold for 150c$ in may 2022. so is this lioness worth .5 ma? tysm for any help <3

[Androys]

hows this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=101001846&userid=989864&signature=Fo4_pSrv1Q5d4_eP2VRSIQ