The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[moonviewing]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100993565&userid=422911&signature=ZuB29Vfia-tkkMqn9905kQ

Feeling this might be unfair by date to me - but maybe horses have less demand - just curious to hear what you all think

yeah, this is unfair to you. their pets equal a 2014 rare at best, and even tho horses have fairly bad demand, its not That bad

[Rem.]

Is this fair, not sure what year this rat is

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000413&userid=897504&signature=TI_KwH4S2dMhIqiLI95rIQ

The rat is from Sept 2009 and yours is from 2010 so unfair to them

[Wysterinka]

Uhh are these fair, and which one is better?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000478&userid=897504&signature=s_LV34IZL_FxpTg3To5Sug

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000413&userid=897504&signature=TI_KwH4S2dMhIqiLI95rIQ

both offers are 09 vr but malk horses have higher demand than rats the guinea piggy is 2010 vr but people often pay double for them so 09 vr could be considered fair

[QueenSiren]

Uhh are these fair, and which one is better?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000478&userid=897504&signature=s_LV34IZL_FxpTg3To5Sug

trades/viewtrade.php?id=101000413&userid=897504&signature=TI_KwH4S2dMhIqiLI95rIQ

both offers are 09 vr but malk horses have higher demand than rats the guinea piggy is 2010 vr but people often pay double for them so 09 vr could be considered fair

Thank you so much <3

[anathema]

UR Cat for Sunjewel?
Fair?

depends on how you personally value the ur cat imo. i've seen the ur cat go for low as 2non and high as 3non with a median value of 2.5, with sunjewel consistently going for 3

[Wysterinka]

UR Cat for Sunjewel?
Fair?

depends on how you personally value the ur cat imo. i've seen the ur cat go for low as 2non and high as 3non with a median value of 2.5, with sunjewel consistently going for 3

agreed on this ^^

[Syberia]

Im pretty sure this is unfair but I do want some opinions since Im not sure about the store pets. If its the case, if I were to remove the ur bw on my side and the items on their side, what would I need to add to make it fair?

Thanks in advance!

[Rem.]

anyone know if this is fair? I have no clue about item worth and couldn't find an C$ to item guide thanks^^ x

[Wysterinka]

Im pretty sure this is unfair but I do want some opinions since Im not sure about the store pets. If its the case, if I were to remove the ur bw on my side and the items on their side, what would I need to add to make it fair?

Thanks in advance!

Dark shima wolf doen't have much data in it but most people trade it for about 3 MA (some get .25 non but I don't know...depends on buyer) so without the UR bwolf or the items I would say their side is: store pets (.5 MA each I think) + 12 09 rares + 2011 r that in total you can consider about 3-4 MA so i would say fair for shima get another opinion because I don't think many people know much of how to trade with this one

[winx]

anyone know if this is fair? I have no clue about item worth and couldn't find an C$ to item guide thanks^^ x

The Horse Plushie is from 2011 Christmas. This would make it worth a 2011 uncommon, possibly pushing towards a 2011 rare given plushie demand. Going off the C$ Guide linked here, a 2011 rare is between 20-25 C$.
[The values in the guide are simply ballpark/estimate values. If you have your own preferred pricing for pets by year, then please feel free to use that since it differs from person to person.]
I would say that 100 C$ is fair/overpay for your 2011 plushie.