The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100921810&userid=900267&signature=9nBJxIOeb9ZxhFJQcXbn0Q

I tried doing an overpay but im not even sure I fit that? want help so I can better understand worths!

The pets you asked for are 2021 store pets I believe. Each would be worth 2010 rare so no, what you offered wouldn't be fair yet

[Ashara]

How does this item trade look? Thanks in advance!

[Spinda]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100920802&userid=958822&signature=MZ5J9KIShoqDC99CmhJtjw[/quote]

50 for 09vr is great price, it could be 80....but the rest is not worth 100 if that's what you meant[/quote]


I read their message wrong this is actually what they said::
I'd take around 150C$ for them
The may 09 I wanna sell for 100 so the others in total would be 50

would this be fair since you said the 09 VR can go for 80?

[inesg]

Not sure if i am making this trade unfair to myself?? Can someone let me know how much this rat is worth?? I know its very rare, but should It be more like 2 rares?
Thank youuuu

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100923060&userid=1046120&signature=nmkfQ0EZEhKKg4p9L1U3pA

[blueberrycat]

Not sure if i am making this trade unfair to myself?? Can someone let me know how much this rat is worth?? I know its very rare, but should It be more like 2 rares?
Thank youuuu

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100923060&userid=1046120&signature=nmkfQ0EZEhKKg4p9L1U3pA

The rat is mid advent according to Horror's list! not fair to yourself

[Zoethian]

Could I have an opinion on the fairness of this trade, please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100920825&userid=262756&signature=e8544eMIkvLNyqiU87yk6w
Thank you in advance!

[Spinda]

Could I have an opinion on the fairness of this trade, please?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100920825&userid=262756&signature=e8544eMIkvLNyqiU87yk6w
Thank you in advance!

Everything is fair except for the two cat items. they are from Christmas 2013. it would be unfair to you if you're the one with the items on your side.

Those items can go for at least one-two 2013 uncommons each depending how the person feels about the item as people value plushies more

[THEaruszkow]

I don't know how fair this is, initially they were offering an Event Deer, but I had already gotten it, but I'm very unsure

[Spinda]

I don't know how fair this is, initially they were offering an Event Deer, but I had already gotten it, but I'm very unsure

The event pets will become between an uncommon to a rare. With them not having their rarity it's a bit hard to determine the value of the pets a little. It honestly depends if you want doubles or not. even if the deer do turn rare, there's people that follow the 2:1 ratio. 2 commons equal an uncommon. so 2 commons plus the 1 uncommon dog could equal 1 rare, equally to one of the deer (if it is to turn to a rare) as 2 uncommons could equal to 1 rare.

It could be slight under pay to the deer, as the 07-22 dog and the lion still don't have their rarity. They may be uncommon but then again they could be common or even below, no rarity pets are quite hard to determine . Sometime people even ask for more for non rarity pets.

This trade either be slightly underpay to the deer or just about right. or to be on the safe side, you could add another common or two or another uncommon from 2022

I hope this make sense and hope it helps!

Personally I would wait for rarities to come, if it were me or do event swaps

[THEaruszkow]

I don't know how fair this is, initially they were offering an Event Deer, but I had already gotten it, but I'm very unsure

The event pets will become between an uncommon to a rare. With them not having their rarity it's a bit hard to determine the value of the pets a little. It honestly depends if you want doubles or not. even if the deer do turn rare, there's people that follow the 2:1 ratio. 2 commons equal an uncommon. so 2 commons plus the 1 uncommon dog could equal 1 rare, equally to one of the deer (if it is to turn to a rare) as 2 uncommons could equal to 1 rare.

It could be slight under pay to the deer, as the 07-22 dog and the lion still don't have their rarity. They may be uncommon but then again they could be common or even below, no rarity pets are quite hard to determine . Something people even ask for more for non rarity pets.

This trade either be slightly underpay to the deer or just about right. or to be on the same side, you could add another common or two or another uncommon from 2022

I hope this make sense and hope it helps!

Personally I would wait for rarities to come, if it were me or do event swaps

Alright thank you for the answer! I'll just see how it pans out I suppose (: