The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[EditPink]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100881934&userid=902320&signature=MghnLhQLfQiXNW82goTdVA

I don't understand they are the same?
I have had a few trades like this
Thanks for any help

Your deer is “ still growing” so it will end up one of the coloured options. Their deer is full grown and won’t be changing.

Did I make the right decision to accept the trade?

[Mavi]

Link
TD Red rose for a RR Blue Toxic?
Does being a True date make it that much more valuable?
(Please forgive me I am used to the old list not the new ones)

[Meep Meep]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100881934&userid=902320&signature=MghnLhQLfQiXNW82goTdVA

I don't understand they are the same?
I have had a few trades like this
Thanks for any help

Your deer is “ still growing” so it will end up one of the coloured options. Their deer is full grown and won’t be changing.

Did I make the right decision to accept the trade?

Out of the 15 deer I got, 3 were full grown so I personally would have taken it.
It’s really up to your preference though. Without the rarities it’s hard to tell if it’s exactly a fair swap.

[rhaenyra]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100809274&userid=1045460&signature=pv9jlA1jpFLC9vWwovtT1Q hi, can i get help with figuring out if this is fair or not? i have no idea aha. thank you for any help!

Yes, this trade is fair! When trading up uncommons to rares, rather than the 2:1 rule, many people prefer the 4:1 rule (1 uncommons of the same year = 1 rare of the same year).

[Funkyfandom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100882092&userid=1004512&signature=rAdPRtLuwG203W3aJxPR_Q

is this fair? i dont use items if that helps

[rats!]

hi guys!! what do you think of this trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=100878656&userid=22963&signature=K35t7u3qoCVMLT21s_Aytg

Thank you in advance for any advice!

[Rem.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100871903&userid=652660&signature=RnDJ7a_wDQlGpIXCvH3L0w
haven't been here in a while i think this is a good trade but just double checking since list doesn't exist anymore

edit ; this too i'd just like to know which has better demand
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100873854&userid=652660&signature=OjO0wWcji4-uRkJ4G6ScYQ

E 2; this i'll probably take solely because the angel advent is a dreamie of mine but got no clue how much this thing goes for
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100874796&userid=652660&signature=7cvoSRCAwvto1PMwQ5fbHQ

[CalicoWolf]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100881559&userid=6076&signature=UP5Uf5O-ezvrQnMttmK9Jw
Thanks in advance.

[Mavi]

Link
TD Red rose for a RR Blue Toxic?
Does being a True date make it that much more valuable?
(Please forgive me I am used to the old list not the new ones)

[daekie]

Is this fair? I'm assuming it might be, since the year difference makes up for the rarity difference, but I'm not sure.