The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[dillydallydarlene]

How fair is this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100874897&userid=47800&signature=OWre4Hrts-fAqEOjr_cdcg

And this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100878776&userid=47800&signature=-m6Qq-2WQKT8w3td5B5y3g

[THEaruszkow]

I have no idea if this is fair due to how many unknown rarities there are, I'm leaning towards yes, but I'd like another opinion

[beeves]

is this fair? not too sure about the large quantity so any help is greatly appreciated <33

[chromatica]

is this fair?

[tabook]

I have no idea if this is fair due to how many unknown rarities there are, I'm leaning towards yes, but I'd like another opinion

My opinion is very amateur but I saw you haven't gotten an answer. I think this is fair for you - they might be overpaying for convenience. It's tough for me personally to tell for the less-than-rare ones. As for the unknown event pets: it's usually safe to assume the Free Adopt event pets will be common to uncommon, and the Token pets will be uncommon to rare. Even though we can guess what they will be, slight overpay for unknown rarities is pretty common. Someone correct me if this is wrong

[Fierceless]

Struggling with this

[Llazybonezz]

Do these deer have high demand?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100876219&userid=631866&signature=grPcwixBSheQDx0o2e-D3w

//edit//
I also just got this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100876897&userid=631866&signature=62LBnwHRbty5-4ZQFy-QHw
Is the second one more fair?

[chirp.]

I have no idea if this is fair due to how many unknown rarities there are, I'm leaning towards yes, but I'd like another opinion

okay i am very much so out of practice with my trading knowledge so you'll DEFINITELY want a second opinion here.

that being said, i'm like 98% sure they're overpaying. even if all your pets turn out to be rare, they're new enough that all of them combined wouldn't add up to the 8 ball pony, which is — unless things have changed in the last five years — the rarest outcome in that litter. personally i would accept it, as this is a very good deal for you, but you should probably let them know they're overpaying if they don't already.

[luckydraw]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100878171&userid=816125&signature=B0mda6vGesOd9HBKwrSAAw

Is this fair for both of us? I’m really horrible when it comes to ex list pet trades. Thank you to anyone who helps in advance!

[musicgurl333]

How fair is this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100874897&userid=47800&signature=OWre4Hrts-fAqEOjr_cdcg

And this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100878776&userid=47800&signature=-m6Qq-2WQKT8w3td5B5y3g

Unsure on the second one. The first one is perfectly fair if you follow the “2:1” rule. Personally, I could go either way here. I feel like 4 commons for one only two years older seems a *bit* much, but it’s also nothing *too* crazy. Three of your pets for their one seems more reasonable to me, but again, it’s perfectly fair by the “2:1 rule”.