The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[silent hill 2]

Fair?

i'd keep the event pets until the rarity gets released, just in case!

[Horror]

Fair?

hard to tell until rarities actually come out;
we can assume the snakes & foxes can do litter swaps
your robot dogs are token pets, and the two hard drive items cover them (as each dog costs 1 of those hourly tokens)

your dragon will likely be common-uncommon at highest since it's litter is free and everyone may get multiples, so that would be a remaining 2022 uncommon max on your side

their 2 2022 very commons = 1 2022 common together
+ the 2022 common they already have = 1 2022 uncommon together, which would be enough for your dragon

their items + 2020 common are overpay

[Horsesrule5000]

Is this fair?

[Supreme]

Can anyone help me with this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100270306&userid=702384&signature=0yG5hqxX2VtQbWItcQ7mHQ

[Horror]

Can anyone help me with this trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100270306&userid=702384&signature=0yG5hqxX2VtQbWItcQ7mHQ

their side adds up to 11 MA, or about 1 NON in nice demand pets

your ur squid can range anywhere from 0.5-1 non (varies heavily), so this is fair to both sides, and their offer is on the high end as well. since your squid is from 2019 and considered "true date", that's probably why

Is this fair?

joker + CEG = 3 nons together (@ 1.5 each)
arabian + basilisk = 0.5 non together (@0.25 each)
sometimes arabians may go up to 0.5, but i wouldn't consider that the stable value yet

their side = 3.5 non together in good demand pets

the sunback has consistently been trading around that value recently, so this is pretty fair to both sides trade data
there is one trade valuing it at 4 nons, though since it's only one i wouldn't consider that part of it's normal value right now

[beeves]

not sure about the worth of the horse on their side, especially in comparison to my store pet. any help is greatly appreciated <3

[vonyx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100274927&userid=535415&signature=wAfo05Ne3_GyCkP335c_Bw

Is that fair quantity for value?

[Tempestbeast]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100219200&userid=429209&signature=mrbEdl5Lvj_7I4Q4G6F7OQ

Is this fair? I am partial to the lion more but they seem to have diffrent demand from what I could tell. If anyone could help me with this I would be very grateful.

[Riley ♥]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100219200&userid=429209&signature=mrbEdl5Lvj_7I4Q4G6F7OQ

Is this fair? I am partial to the lion more but they seem to have diffrent demand from what I could tell. If anyone could help me with this I would be very grateful.

Zodiac dogs are worth 2-3 2009 rares ( x ), and a 2015 store pet is also worth 2-3 2009 rares ( x ), so this is a fair trade. You might be thinking of the PPS lion that comes with this store set, which is worth a few more rares than the rest of the set due to the PPS pets of a store set being in slightly higher demand.

[Riley ♥]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100274927&userid=535415&signature=wAfo05Ne3_GyCkP335c_Bw

Is that fair quantity for value?

Those are all newer pets, and they would have to have hundreds (if not thousands x ) of uncommons on their side in order to make it equal a 2009 rare. When trading down like that, having large year gaps just isn't feasible for the most part, and you'll almost never get a fair trade. This one isn't fair to you at all.