The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[musicgurl333]

I would really appreciate some help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100232970&userid=100368&signature=jYIZAP-AWHbFxjetpeeAWQ

most items (or sets) are worth a common to uncommon of the year they were released. i am not aware of special demand for either items, though from what i have seen medieval pets/items tend to have higher general demand & the lancelot plushie is a collectible, for those who like plushies and complete item sets.

imo, overpay for them.

Strong disagree. Both items are from 2011, and given their age can safely be considered uncommons, rather than commons. The pets on the top aren’t enough to equal two ‘11 uncommons. Plus, plushies have decent demand as far as items go, and rats don’t. There’s no way I would accept this if it was me.

[TeknoNeko]

Internet Event Pets for 2021 - 2022 Uncommons + Common Is this fair on both sides?

[oluvia]

thoughts,?
thank you,! < 3

hello! im on the other side and would like help as well! thank you!

[musicgurl333]

Internet Event Pets for 2021 - 2022 Uncommons + Common Is this fair on both sides?

Hard to say because of the unknowns. It also depends on how you value uncommons to rares. If you think the pets on your side are all rares, and you strictly stick to the “2:1 rule” (2 ‘22 rares = 1 ‘21 rare, and 2 uncommons = 1 rare), then the common on their side isn’t needed.

If you value your pets as rares and use the “2:1 rule” for years, but value a rare as 4 uncommons (which is a pretty common valuation…I personally value rares as 3-5 uncommons), then it’s unfair to you.

If you value your pets as uncommons, then it’s definitely unfair to them.

[TeknoNeko]

Internet Event Pets for 2021 - 2022 Uncommons + Common Is this fair on both sides?

Hard to say because of the unknowns. It also depends on how you value uncommons to rares. If you think the pets on your side are all rares, and you strictly stick to the “2:1 rule” (2 ‘22 rares = 1 ‘21 rare, and 2 uncommons = 1 rare), then the common on their side isn’t needed.

If you value your pets as rares and use the “2:1 rule” for years, but value a rare as 4 uncommons (which is a pretty common valuation…I personally value rares as 3-5 uncommons), then it’s unfair to you.

If you value your pets as uncommons, then it’s definitely unfair to them.

Thank you! I normally value unknowns as Uncommon, but I've seen event pets generally being valued as Rares so that's what I've been basing them on

[serl]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100102241&userid=529624&signature=0-jNgde5gPsQEtO_J73Afw

thanks for any help! dont wanna let this one rot

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100253959&userid=529624&signature=WTjk6uht_LEOQhJRJJ7eUA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100254579&userid=529624&signature=4YHBNOAb0GgzF8oKPzNm3A

these too! ty!

[oluvia]

thoughts,?
thank you,! < 3

hello! im on the other side and would like help as well! thank you!

[smiledawg]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100255693&userid=865121&signature=fo7mEbWjYFac_j8s9zhzqQ

help!

[shepherd's dog]

I would really appreciate some help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100232970&userid=100368&signature=jYIZAP-AWHbFxjetpeeAWQ

most items (or sets) are worth a common to uncommon of the year they were released. i am not aware of special demand for either items, though from what i have seen medieval pets/items tend to have higher general demand & the lancelot plushie is a collectible, for those who like plushies and complete item sets.

imo, overpay for them.

Strong disagree. Both items are from 2011, and given their age can safely be considered uncommons, rather than commons. The pets on the top aren’t enough to equal two ‘11 uncommons. Plus, plushies have decent demand as far as items go, and rats don’t. There’s no way I would accept this if it was me.

oh my god, absolutely my bad! i was thinking they were from 2016 for some reason.
100% you are in the correct. this is a very unfair trade for you.

[CoffeeEX]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100255034&userid=881679&signature=OSvLVod5kJmgi6JPErQ0nA

howdy! just wondering if this is fair, and if not can i know why? tyty!