The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TibblesNbits]

Going through older trades, so i would like some help so I can properly finally answer some people.
Please ignore the bunny, I will be removing that from the trade as I don't need that bunny.

So with ignoring the bunny, would this be fair for my items for the other two pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97198459&userid=958822&signature=TxiP_xQPi7oJLivZNRd7lw

Also How much does this trade equal up to , to make it fair please?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99751953&userid=958822&signature=jpFJvUg3XIgcmSx3NNgkxg

For the first one ignoring the bunny, the first few items minus the blond wig are 2009 store items that are still in the store and not the full set, the blond wig is from 2011, and the rest are 2019 to 2021. They are slightly overpaying in terms of C$ because of the store items are still in the C$ store.

The second trade is nine Ma and one to two 2009 rares for the slanted eyes.

[Eurydice]

Trade

They literally cited trades in the message they sent i just want confirmation because I am really illiterate in CS rarity >.<

You might want a second opinion but if I'm right the car is 1 ma and the zodiac is 2-3 '09 rares (I'm sure about zodiac worth;; not entirely sure about the sitting Cats!)

Which in your case would put you over since the alpaca is already 1 ma and the other 2013 store pet goes for 0.5-1 MA,, (in that case already making this trade over)

Let alone if you consider that the PPS fennec fox can often grab higher than it's worth due to demand !

Second opinion here, I agree with everything stated above. You're overpaying by quite a bit. I recommend editing down.

Thank you guys! I thought it was overpay because I was p sure the cat was 1 Ma and the person has it listed as "2 MA" cause they overpaid for it. Will be cancelling!

[QuietRebel]

Is this fair?
Trade

[Flicka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99598996&userid=9355&signature=QPIUzdbDvkqoJHHvDEOGxg is this fair?

[mikuscreations]

May I get help please? I got this trade and I know that some of these are in fact higher than what they're offering

They're going by "40 C$ per rat | 45 C$ per butterfly wolf | 50 C$ per dog"

Can you guys let me know how much more I should be asking or maybe the values of the higher end pets??

Thanks so much !

It depends on the pet, could you link the trade so we can value the pets?

MY BAD!! Thought I linked it <3

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=99750059&userid=571194&signature=g5H2OoEwIGBUgcTQDJM5rg

[opaliss]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99752945&userid=947010&signature=EmYU7qtwpOTRfKllBO5hfQ

help?

[Spinda]

I threw piles of uncommons in, please tell me if this is unfair to the rares or over pay or roughly just about right.

I am making up difference for years and rarity, I don't mind over paying a little if this is the case

Big help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99753560&userid=958822&signature=gP8asywtuyHvLgX_PIarpg

[NoProperTea]

I'm really tempted to take this but wanted to check - is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99748550&userid=198931&signature=2uPZaDAEstINjiA77awrVQ

[Cyll]

I threw piles of uncommons in, please tell me if this is unfair to the rares or over pay or roughly just about right.

I am making up difference for years and rarity, I don't mind over paying a little if this is the case

Big help

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99753560&userid=958822&signature=gP8asywtuyHvLgX_PIarpg

I am far from an expert and would recommend getting a second opinion, but I don’t think it’s fair to them. The cat, the zodiac, and (I think) the lion are all worth more than a standard 2009 rare in terms of demand. I’m not sure about the others but I believe I’ve seen sitting cats valued at 1MA which is six 2009 rares if I’m remembering correctly.

Completely ignoring that I don’t think the uncommons add up, I think you’d need more 2009 or 2010 uncommons to add up to those older rares. The items are both from 2021 so they don’t add too much value to the trade as far as I’m aware.

[Smil3dawg]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=99754226&userid=865121&signature=W9dKsY0fiieRETFRwT4Dlw idk with this one plz help!